Chapter X.
The Divinity of the Holy Spirit is supported by a passage of St. John. This passage was,
indeed, erased by heretics, but it is a vain attempt, since their faithlessness could thereby
more easily be convicted. The order of the context is considered in order that this passage
may be shown to refer to the Spirit. He is born of the Spirit who is born again of the same
Spirit, of Whom Christ Himself is believed to have been born and born again. Again, the
Godhead of the Spirit is inferred from two testimonies of St. John; and lastly, it is explained
how the Spirit, the water, and the blood are called witnesses.
59. Nor does the Scripture in this place alone bear witness to the θεότης, that is, the
Godhead of the Holy Spirit; but also the Lord Himself said in the Gospel: “The Spirit is
God.”525 Which passage you, Arians, so expressly testify to be said concerning the Spirit,
that you remove it from your copies,526 and would that it were from yours and not also
from those of the Church! For at the time when Auxentius527 had seized the Church of
Milan with the arms and forces of impious unbelief, the Church of Sirmium528 was attacked
by Valens and Ursatius, when their priests [i.e. bishops] failed in faith; this falsehood and
sacrilege of yours was found in the ecclesiastical books. And it may chance that you did the
same in the past.
60. And you have indeed been able to blot out the letters, but could not remove the
faith. That erasure betrayed you more, that erasure condemned you more; and you were
not able to obliterate the truth, but that erasure blotted out your names from the book of
life. Why was the passage removed, “For God is a Spirit,” if it did not pertain to the Spirit?
525 S. John iii. 6. See below § 63, n. 4.
526 “The charge is an admirable illustration of the groundlessness of such accusations of wilful corruption
of Scripture. The words in question have no Greek authority at all, and are obviously a comment.” Westcott on
S. John v. 6.
527 Auxentius, a Cappadocian, was ordained priest a.d. 343 by Gregory, the violent opponent of St. Athanas-
ius. After the synod of Milan a.d. 355, when the bishop of that see, Dionysius, having refused to renounce Ath-
anasius and the Nicene faith, was banished, Auxentius was forcibly intruded as bishop, and, in spite of the efforts
of St. Hilary of Poitiers and other Catholics, maintained his position till his death in 374.
528 The reference must be to the synods of Sirmium. In one held a.d. 351, against Photinus, there was a great
attempt to make the semi-Arians appear orthodox, and St. Hilary accepted, while St. Athanasius rejected, their
formula. Another synod was held a.d. 357, when the aged Hosius was tormented into accepting a formula, called
by St. Hilary the “Sirmian blasphemy.” Another, no less injurious to the faith, was held in 358, by the desire of
Constantius. During this time—but forgeries and the loss of some patristic writings make the history of the
whole period somewhat uncertain—dates the weakness of Liberius, so that St. Ambrose may well speak of
nutantibus sacerdotibus. See Hefele, Conc. Geschichte, I. on the Sirmian synods; Athanasius, Vol. IV. in this
series, p. 464 ff.; Dict. Chr. Biog. III. 171, art. “Hosius;” Socrates, H. E., in this series, Vol. II. pp. 56, 57, 58.
Chapter X. The Divinity of the Holy Spirit is supported by a passage of St. John. This passage was, indeed, erased by heretics, but it is a vain attempt, since their faithlessness could thereby more easily be convicted. The order of the context is considered in order that this passage may be shown to refer to the Spirit. He is born of the Spirit who is born again of the same Spirit, of Whom Christ Himself is believed to have been born and born again. Again, the Godhead of the Spirit is inferred from two testimonies of St. John; and lastly, it is explained how the Spirit, the water, and the blood are called witnesses.
342
Chapter X. The Divinity of the Holy Spirit is supported by a passage of…