For, proceeding with his
discourse, he asks us what we mean by the ages. And yet we ourselves
might more reasonably put such questions to him. For it is he who
professes to know the essence of God, defining on his own authority
what is unapproachable and incomprehensible by man. Let him, then, give
us a scientific lecture on the nature of the ages, boasting as he does
of his familiarity with transcendental things, and let him
not so fiercely brandish over us, poor ignorant individuals, the double
danger of the dilemma involved in our reply, telling us that, whether
we hold this or that view of the ages, the result must be in either
case an absurdity. For if (says he) you say that they are eternal, you
will be Greeks, and Valentinians Valentinus “placed in the pleroma (so the Gnostics
called the habitation of the Deity) thirty æons (ages), of
which one half were male, and the other female” (Mosheim),
i.e. these æons were co-eternal with the Deity., and
uninstructed βάρβαροι here being not opposed to “Greeks” must imply
mere inability to speak aright: amongst those who claimed to use
Catholic language another “barbarism,” or
“jargon,” had arisen (i.e. that of heresy, whether
Platonist or Gnostic), different from that which separated the Greeks
from the Jews, Africans, Romans alike. Hesychius; βάρβαροι
οἱ
ἀπαίδευτοι. So to S. Paul “the people” of Malta
(Acts
xxviii. 2–4), as to others the Apostles, were barbarian.: and if you say that they are
generate, you will no longer be able to ascribe ungeneracy to God. What
a terribly unanswerable attack! If, O Eunomius, something is held to be
generate, we no longer hold the doctrine of the Divine ungeneracy! And
pray what has become of your subtle distinctions between generacy and
ungeneracy, by which you sought to establish the dissimilarity of the
essence of the Son from that of the Father? For it seems from what we
are now being taught that the Father is not dissimilar in essence when
contemplated in respect of generacy, but that, in fact, if we hold His
ungeneracy, we reduce Him to non-existence; since “if we speak of
the ages as generate, we are driven to relinquish the
Ungenerate.” But let us examine the force of the argument, by
which he would compel us to allow this absurdity. When, says he, those
things by comparison with which God is without beginning are
non-existent, He Who is compared with them must be non-existent also.
What a sturdy and overpowering grip is this! How tightly has this
wrestler got us by the waist in his inextricable grasp! He says that
God’s ungeneracy is added to Him through comparison with the
ages. By whom is it so added? Who is there that says that to Him Who
hath no beginning ungeneracy is added as an acquisition through
comparison with something else? Neither such a word nor such a sense
will be found in any writings of ours. Our words indeed carry their own
justification, and contain nothing like what is alleged against us; and
of the meaning of what is said, who can be a more trustworthy
interpreter than he who said it? Have not we, then, the better title to
say what we mean when we speak of the life of God as extending beyond
the ages? And what we say is what we have said already in our previous
writings. But, says he, comparison with the ages being impossible, it
is impossible that any addition should accrue from it to God, meaning
of course that ungeneracy is an addition. Let him tell us by whom such
an addition has been made. If by himself, he becomes simply ridiculous
in laying his own folly to our charge: if by us, let him quote our
words, and then we will admit the force of his accusation.