namely, the nomination and ordination of bishops, and the superior position of the metro-
politan. The third point connected with this division—namely, the provincial synod—will
be considered under the next canon.
Meletius was probably the occasion of this canon. It may be remembered that he had
nominated bishops without the concurrence of the other bishops of the province, and
without the approval of the metropolitan of Alexandria, and had thus occasioned a schism.
This canon was intended to prevent the recurrence of such abuses. The question has been
raised as to whether the fourth canon speaks only of the choice of the bishop, or whether it
also treats of the consecration of the newly elected. We think, with Van Espen, that it treats
equally of both,—as well of the part which the bishops of the province should take in an
episcopal election, as of the consecration which completes it.
This canon has been interpreted in two ways. The Greeks had learnt by bitter experience
to distrust the interference of princes and earthly potentates in episcopal elections. Accord-
ingly, they tried to prove that this canon of Nice took away from the people the right of
voting at the nomination of a bishop, and confined the nomination exclusively to the bishops
of the province.
The Greek Commentators, Balsamon and others, therefore, only followed the example
of the Seventh and [so-called] Eighth Œcumenical Councils in affirming that this fourth
canon of Nice takes away from the people the right previously possessed of voting in the
choice of bishops and makes the election depend entirely on the decision of the bishops of
the province.
The Latin Church acted otherwise. It is true that with it also the people have been re-
moved from episcopal elections, but this did not happen till later, about the eleventh century;
and it was not the people only who were removed, but the bishops of the province as well,
and the election was conducted entirely by the clergy of the Cathedral Church. The Latins
then interpreted the canon of Nice as though it said nothing of the rights of the bishops of
the province in the election of their future colleague (and it does not speak of it in a very
explicit manner), and as though it determined these two points only; (a) that for the ordin-
ation of a bishop three bishops at least are necessary; (b) that the right of confirmation rests
with the metropolitan.
The whole subject of episcopal elections is treated fully by Van Espen and by Thomassin,
in Ancienne et Nouvelle Discipline de l’ Église, P. II. l. 2.
This canon is found in the Corpus Juris Canonici, Gratian’s Decretum, Pars I. Dist. LXIV.
c. j.
57
Canon IV.