Chapter XX.—The
Epistle to the Philippians. The Variances Amongst the Preachers of
Christ No Argument that There Was More Than One Only Christ. St.
Paul’s Phrases—Form of a Servant, Likeness, and Fashion of
a Man—No Sanction of Docetism. No Antithesis (Such as Marcion
Alleged) in the God of Judaism and the God of the Gospel Deducible from
Certain Contrasts Mentioned in This Epistle. A Parallel with a Passage
in Genesis. The Resurrection of the Body, and the Change
Thereof.
When (the apostle) mentions the several motives of
those who were preaching the gospel, how that some, “waxing
confident by his bonds, were more fearless in speaking the word,”
while others “preached Christ even out of envy and strife, and
again others out of good-will,” many also “out of
love,” and certain “out of contention,” and some
“in rivalry to himself,”
6096
he had a
favourable opportunity, no doubt,
6097
of taxing what
they preached with a diversity of doctrine, as if it were no less than
this which caused so great a variance in their tempers. But while he
exposes these tempers as the sole cause of the diversity, he avoids
inculpating the regular mysteries of the faith,
6098
and affirms that there is, notwithstanding, but one Christ and His one
God, whatever motives men had in preaching Him. Therefore, says
he, it matters not to me “whether it be in pretence or in truth
that Christ is preached,”
6099
because one
Christ alone was announced, whether in their “pretentious”
or their “truthful” faith. For it was to the faithfulness
of their preaching that he applied the word
truth
, not to the
rightness of the rule itself, because there was indeed but one rule;
whereas the conduct of the preachers varied: in some of them it was
true,
i.e.
single-minded, while in others it was sophisticated
with over-much learning. This being the case, it is manifest that
that Christ was the subject of their preaching who was always the theme
of the prophets. Now, if it were a completely different Christ that was
being introduced by the apostle, the novelty of the thing would have
produced a diversity (in belief.). For there would not have been
wanting, in spite of the novel teaching,
6100
men to interpret the preached gospel of the Creator’s Christ,
since the majority of persons everywhere now-a-days are of our way of
thinking, rather than on the heretical side. So that the apostle would
not in such a passage as the present one have refrained from remarking
and censuring the diversity. Since, however, there is no blame of
a diversity, there is no proof of a novelty. Of course
6101
the Marcionites suppose that they have the
apostle on their side in the following passage in the matter of
Christ’s substance—that in Him there was nothing but a
phantom of flesh. For he says of Christ, that, “being in the form
of God, He thought it not robbery to be equal with God;
6102
but emptied
6103
Himself, and took upon Him the
form
of a servant,”
not
the reality
, “and was made in the
likeness
of
man,”
not a man
, “and was found in
fashion
as
a man,”
6104
not in his
substance
, that is to say, his flesh; just as if to a
sub
stance there did
not accrue both
form
and
likeness
and
fashion
. It
is well for us that in another passage (the apostle) calls Christ
“the image of the invisible God.”
6105
For will it not follow with equal force from that passage, that Christ
is not truly God, because the apostle places Him in
the image
of
God, if, (as Marcion contends,) He is not truly man because of His
having taken on Him
the form
or
image
of a man? For in
both cases the true substance will have to be excluded, if
image
(or “fashion”) and
likeness
and
form
shall be
claimed for a phantom. But since he is truly God, as the Son of the
Father, in His fashion and image, He has been already by the force of
this conclusion determined to be truly man, as the Son of man,
“found in the fashion” and image “of a
man.” For when he propounded
6106
Him as thus “
found
” in the manner
6107
of a man, he
in fact
affirmed Him to
be most certainly human. For what is
found
, manifestly possesses
existence. Therefore, as He was found to be God by His mighty power, so
was He found to be man by reason of His flesh, because the apostle
could not have pronounced Him to have “become obedient unto
death,”
6108
if He had not been
constituted of a mortal substance. Still more plainly does this appear
from the apostle’s additional words, “even the death of the
cross.”
6109
For he could hardly
mean this to be a climax
6110
to the human
suffering, to extol the virtue
6111
of His obedience,
if he had known it all to be the imaginary process of a phantom, which
rather eluded the cross than experienced it, and which displayed no
virtue
6112
in the suffering,
but only illusion. But “those things which he had once accounted
gain,” and which he enumerates in the preceding
verse—“trust in the flesh,” the sign of
“circumcision,” his origin as “an Hebrew of the
Hebrews,” his descent from “the tribe of Benjamin,”
his dignity in the honours of the Pharisee
6113
—he now reckons to be only
“loss” to himself;
6114
(in other words,)
it was not the God of the Jews, but their stupid obduracy, which he
repudiates. These are also the things “which he counts but dung
for the excellency of the knowledge of Christ”
6115
(but by no means for the rejection of God
the Creator); “whilst he has not his own righteousness, which is
of the law, but that which is through Him,”
i.e.
Christ,
“the righteousness which is of God.”
6116
Then, say you, according to this distinction
the law did not proceed from the God of Christ. Subtle enough!
But here is something still more subtle for you. For when (the apostle)
says, “Not (the righteousness) which is of the law, but that
which is through Him,” he would not have used the phrase
through Him
of any other than Him to whom the law belonged.
“Our conversation,” says he, “is in
heaven.”
6117
I here recognise
the Creator’s ancient promise to Abraham: “I will multiply
thy seed as the stars of heaven.”
6118
Therefore “one star differeth from another star in
glory.”
6119
If, again, Christ
in His advent from heaven “shall change the body of our
humiliation, that it may be fashioned like unto His glorious
body,”
6120
it follows that
this body of ours shall rise again, which is now in a state of
humiliation in its sufferings and according to the law of mortality
drops into the ground. But how shall it be changed, if it shall have no
real existence? If, however, this is only said of those who shall be
found in the flesh
6121
at the advent of
God, and who shall have to be changed,”
6122
what shall they do who will rise first? They will have no
substance from which to undergo a change. But he says (elsewhere),
“We shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet
the Lord (in the air).”
6123
Then, if we are to
be caught up alone with them, surely we shall likewise be changed
together with them.
6096
Phil. i. 14–17
.
6097
Utique.
6098
Regulas
sacramentorum.
6099
Phil. i. 18
.
6100
Nihilominus.
6101
Plane.
6102
Compare the treatise,
De Resur. Carnis
, c. vi. (Oehler).
6103
Exhausit
ἐκένωσε
.
6104
Phil. ii. 6, 7
.
6105
Col. i. 15
.
6106
Posuit.
6107
Inventum ratione.
6108
Phil. ii. 8
.
6109
Phil. ii. 8
.
6110
Non enim
exaggeraret.
6111
Virtutem:
perhaps the
power
.
6112
See the preceding
note.
6113
Candidæ
pharisaeæ: see
Phil. iii.
4–6
.
6114
Phil. iii. 7
.
6115
Phil. iii. 8
.
6116
Phil. iii. 9
.
6117
Phil. iii. 20
.
6118
Gen. xxii. 17
.
6119
1 Cor. xv. 41
.
6120
Phil. iii. 21
. [I have adhered to the original Greek,
by a trifling verbal change, because Tertullian’s argument
requires it.]
6121
1 Cor. xv. 51, 52
.
6122
Deputari
, which
is an old reading, should certainly be
demutari
, and so say the
best authorities. Oehler reads the former, but contends for the
latter.
6123
1 Thess. iv. 16, 17
.