3. But others, including Plato, who is in such
repute among the Greeks, argue that God has made the world out of
matter previously existing and without beginning. For God could have
made nothing had not the material existed already; just as the wood
must exist ready at hand for the carpenter, to enable him to work at
all. 4. But in so saying they know not that they are investing God with
weakness. For if He is not Himself the cause of the material, but makes
things only of previously existing material, He proves to be weak,
because unable to produce anything He makes without the material; just
as it is without doubt a weakness of the carpenter not to be able to
make anything required without his timber. For, ex hypothesi,
had not the material existed, God would not have made anything. And how
could He in that case be called Maker and Artificer, if He owes His
ability to make to some other source—namely, to the material? So
that if this be so, God will be on their theory a Mechanic only, and
not a Creator out of nothing εἰς τὸ
εἶναι.; if, that is, He
works at existing material, but is not Himself the cause of the
material. For He could not in any sense be called Creator unless He is
Creator of the material of which the things created have in their turn
been made. 5. But the sectaries imagine to themselves a different
artificer of all things, other than the Father of our Lord Jesus
Christ, in deep blindness even as to the words they use. 6. For whereas
the Lord says to the Jews Matt. xix. 4,
&c.: “Have ye not
read that from the beginning He which created them made them male and
female, and said, For this cause shall a man leave his father and
mother, and shall cleave to his wife, and they twain shall become one
flesh?” and then, referring to the Creator, says, “What,
therefore, God hath joined together let not
man put asunder:” how come these men to assert that the creation
is independent of the Father? Or if, in the words of John, who says,
making no exception, “All things John i. 3. were
made by Him,” and “without Him was not anything
made,” how could the artificer be another, distinct from the
Father of Christ?