Immediately after the Acacian Synod at Antioch
early in 358, George of Laodicea, who had reasons of his own for
indignation against Eudoxius, wrote off in hot haste to warn Basil of
the fearful encouragement that was being given to the doctrines of
Aetius in that city. Basil, who was in communication (through Hilary)
with Phœbadius and his colleagues, had invited twelve neighbouring
bishops to the dedication of a church in Ancyra at this time, and took
the opportunity of drawing up a synodical letter insisting on the
Essential Likeness of the Son to the Father (ὅμοιον
κατ᾽
οὐσίαν), and eighteen anathemas
directed against Marcellus and the Anomœans. (The censure of ὁμοούσιον
ἢ
ταὐτοούσιον
is against the Marcellian sense of the ὁμοούσιον).
Basil, Eustathius, and Eleusius then proceeded to the Court at Sirmium
and were successful in gaining the ear of the Emperor, who at this time
had a high regard for Basil, and apparently obtained the ratification
by a council, at which Valens, &c., were present, of a composite
formula of their own (Newman’s ‘semi-Arian digest of three
Confessions’) which was also signed by Liberius, who was
thereupon sent back to Rome. (Soz. iv. 15 is our only authority here,
and his account of the formula is not very clear: he seems to mean that
two, not three, confessions were combined. (Cf. p. 449, note 4.) On the
whole, it is most probable that the ‘fourth’ Antiochene
formula in its Sirmian recension of 351 is intended, perhaps with the
addition of twelve of the Ancyrene anathemas. (The question of the
signatures of Liberius need not detain us.) The party of Valens were
involved in sudden and unlooked-for discomfiture. Basil even succeeded
in obtaining a decree of banishment against Eudoxius, Aetius, and
‘seventy’ others (Philost. iv. 8). But an Arian deputation
from Syria procured their recall, and all parties stood at bay in
mutual bitterness.