But let us examine a still more vehement charge of his against us; it is this: “If one must
proceed to say something harsher still, he does not even keep the Divine substance pure
and unadulterated from inferior and contradictory elements.” This is the charge, but the
proof of it is,—what? Observe the strong professional attack! “If He is imperishable only by
reason of the unending in His Life, and ungenerate only by reason of the unbeginning, then
wherein He is not imperishable He is perishable, and wherein He is not ungenerate He is
generated.” Then returning to the charge, he repeats, “He will then be, as unbeginning, at
once ungenerate and perishable, and, as unending, at once imperishable and generated.”
Such is his “harsher” statement, which, according to his threat, he has discharged against
us, to prove that we say that the Divine substance is mingled with contradictory and even
inferior elements. However, I think it is plain to all who keep unimpaired within themselves
the power of judging the truth, that our Master has given no handle at all, in what he has
said, to this calumniator, but that the latter has garbled it at will, and then, playing at arguing,
301
has drawn out this childish sophistry. But that it may be plainer still to all my readers, I will
repeat that statement of the Master word for word, and then confront Eunomius’ words
with it. “We call the Universal Deity” (he says) “imperishable and ungenerate, using these
words with different applications1196 of thought; for when we concentrate our view upon
the ages behind us, we find the life of the Deity transcending every limit, and so name Him
‘ungenerate’; but when we turn our thoughts upon the ages to come, we call the infinite in
Him, the boundless, the absence of all end to His living, ‘imperishability.’ As, then, this
endlessness is called imperishable, so too this beginninglessness is called ungenerate; and
we arrive at these names by Conception.” Such are the Master’s words, and by them he
teaches us this: that the Divine Life is essentially single and continuous with Itself, starting
from no beginning, circumscribed by no end; and that the intuitions which we possess re-
garding this Life it is possible to make clear by words. That is, we express the never having
come from any cause by the term unbeginning or ungenerate; and we express the not being
circumscribed by any limit, and not being destroyed by any death, by the term imperishable,
or unending; and this absence of cause, he defines, makes it right for us to speak of the Divine
life as existing ungenerately; and this being without end we are to denote as imperishable,
since anything that has ceased to exist is necessarily in a state of annihilation, and when we
hear of anything annihilated, we at once think of the destruction of its substance. He says
then, that One Who never ceases to exist, and is a stranger to all destruction and dissolution,
is to be called imperishable.
What, then, does Eunomius say to this? “If He is imperishable only by reason of the
unending in His Life, and ungenerate only by reason of the unbeginning, then wherein He
is not imperishable He is perishable, and wherein He is not ungenerate He is generated.”
1196 ἐπιβολὰς.
564
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.