The view opened to us through this long series of
letters into the mind and character of the great Gregory is of peculiar
interest. The man himself stands out before us therein
self-disclosed; his very faults and frailties, which a panegyrist would
have veiled, giving life and reality to the picture. We may
observe in the first place how conspicuous throughout is his
unhesitating faith. No cloud of doubt seems to have cast
its shadow on his certainty of the truth of Holy Writ and Christianity,
and of the divine authority of the Catholic Church, speaking through
Fathers and Councils as its exponents. Nor were either his
temperament or his training such as to expose him to philosophic
questionings. No less clear is the sincerity of his life as
inspired and guided by his religious faith. Whatever inferior
human motives may appear sometimes, there can be no doubt that his
paramount aim was to devote himself to God’s service. As
was to be expected from the religious ideas of his age, his theory of
the Christian life was ascetic in the extreme. Continual
compunction, fear of judgment, fastings, tears, almsgiving, and
heavenly contemplation, formed his ideal of holiness. Even lawful
marriage he seems to tolerate, as a Zoar of escape from temptation,
rather than to approve: and for a man to enjoy life as most
people aim at doing—to sit, as it were, under his vine and under
his fig-tree—appeared to him at any rate fraught with
danger. Hence the more of both sexes that were able, and could be
induced, to leave the active duties of life for monastic seclusion, the
better he regarded it for them and for the world in whose behalf they
might thus have leisure to pray. Still, on the other hand, such
ascetic views were not found incompatible in his case with tender
regard for others in their earthly joys and sorrows, and interest in
their family life, as expressed in many kind and sympathetic letters to
friends; and he was ever ready to meet their temporal as well as
spiritual needs. His charitable donations in all directions were
bounded only by his means; all oppression of the poor had in him a
resolute opponent; nor can we but be struck by his keen sense of
justice and regard for it in all his dealings. His gentle
breeding, aided by Christian culture, induced a tone of courtesy, with
delicate consideration for the feelings of others, in his letters
generally; and he usually softens even rebuke with gentleness.
Partly, it may be, to this habit may be traced the tone of flattery,
which has been remarked on elsewhere, in his letters to potentates, or
to others whom it was his purpose to conciliate; which was such indeed
in some cases as to lay him open to a charge of insincerity. On
the other hand, however, it is to be remembered
that, when strongly moved, he could write with
very outspoken boldness, not without a vein of cutting irony, even to
the Emperor. Witness his two letters (V. 40; VII. 33) to
Mauricius on the two subjects that appear above all others to
have distressed and irritated him. In such letters—and
especially in some to various correspondents about the title of
“Universal Bishop”—there are symptoms, no doubt, of
much personal irritation, intensified perhaps by gout, under provoking
circumstances. But, if his politic flattery in some cases, and
his irritability in others, are to some minds disappointing in a saint,
they are interesting to a student of human nature: and it is
greatly to his credit that they nowhere indicate any merely selfish
aims, but rather zeal—however alloyed by policy or by
bitterness—for what he honestly believed to be the cause of
God.