SECT. IX.
Mr. W.‘s inconsistence with himself, in what he says in answer to my third and fourth
arguments, and in his reply to my arguments from the Acts, and the Epistles.
The last thing observed in Mr. W.‘s way of disputing, is his alleging and insisting on
things wherein he is inconsistent with himself. His inconsistencies are of many sorts.
Sometimes he alleges those things that are inconsistent with the doctrine of those whose
principles he pretends to maintain.—He abundantly urges those things against my scheme,
which are in like manner against his own. He often argues against those things which he
allows, and strenuously insists on. He denies what he affirms, and affirms what he utterly
denies; laying down and urging those things which are contrary to what he says in other
books; and sometimes contrary to what he says in the same book. Yielding up the thing
wherein the argument lies, yet strenuously maintaining the argument.—Allowing both
premises and consequence, yet finding fault, and opposing. Sometimes he urges things
which are contrary to what he says under different arguments; and sometimes contrary to
what he says under the same argument. Sometimes he contradicts himself in the plain sense
and meaning of what he says; at other times even in plain terms. Sometimes in effect contra-
dicting himself in the same breath, and in the same sentence.
These various kinds of inconsistence have many of them been already observed. And
will further appear by a particular consideration of what he says on several heads, in what
remains.
In my third argument, I insisted, that it could not be much to God’s honour, for men
to profess the assent of their judgment to the true religion, without pretending to any real
friendship or love to God in their hearts. Mr. W. in opposition, (p. 34. d. e.) speaks of it as
an honour to God, that secret hypocrites openly declare their conviction of the truth of
God’s word, &c. as in the multitude of subjects is the king’s honour. And yet he himself rep-
resents the matter quite otherwise in his sermons on Christ a King and Witness; there (p.
87. a.) he has these words, ” to promote the kingdom of Christ, is not to do that which may
prevail with men to make pretences that they are Christians, or that they own Jesus Christ
as their Saviour, and to call him Lord, Lord, when really he is not so.”
In answer to my fourth argument (p. 35. d.) Mr. W. says, I make great misrepresentation
of the matter, in insinuating that according to Mr. S—d’s scheme, (of which scheme he de-
clares himself to be,) they who are admitted make a pretence of no more than moral sincerity,
and common grace. And yet he insists, that when Philip required a profession of the eunuch’s
faith his question designed no more than an assent of the understanding, (p. 51. a. b.) which
he there distinguishes from saving faith: and says, that it is morally certain that his inquiry
amounted to no more. And yet in his discourse on the same head (p. 49. c.) he inveighs
against me for supposing it a consequence of the opinion of my opposers, that the eunuch,
in order to come to sacraments, had no need to look at any such qualification in himself as
SECTION IX. Mr. W. is inconsistent with himself.
1995
SECTION IX. Mr. W. is inconsistent with himself.