obstinate sinners, deal deceitfully and falsely when they pretend to covenant with God.” But
so do all unregenerate sinners under the gospel, according to Mr. Stoddard and his own
doctrine. And thus the very point, about which he contests so earnestly and so long, and
with so many great words, is, in the midst of it all, given up fully, by his own concession.
VII. Mr. W. is greatly displeased with my saying (as above) that none who are under
the power of a carnal mind can visibly own the covenant, without lying or being deceived,
&c. And he finds great fault with my gloss on Psal. lxxviii. 36, 37. “They did flatter him with
their mouth, and lied to him with their tongue:” which I interpret, as though they lied in
pretending that respect to God, which indeed they had not. (p. 35. a. of my Inquiry.) But
he insists, that what is meant is only their lying in breaking their promise. (p. 24. e.) And he
insists upon it, (as has been observed already,) that natural men may covenant with God
and speak true. But it seems he has wonderfully changed his mind of late; for a little while
ago he declared elsewhere for the very same things which he here inveighs against, and spoke
of natural men’s profession and pretence of respect to God, as being actually a lie in its own
nature; and not only becoming so by their breaking covenant afterwards. Particularly, it is
remarkable, he has thus interpreted this very text now in dispute. In his sermons on Christ
a King and Witness, speaking of the outward acts of worship done by those that do not love
God nor believe in Christ, he expressly says, (p. 77.) ‘They are in their own nature a lie; a
false pretence of something within, that is not there.—See (says Mr. W.) this interpretation
of it, in Psal. lxxviii. 34-37. “They did flatter him with their mouths; they lied to him with
their tongues,” &c.—(Ibid. p. 74. b. e.) “Christ’s visible church are such as visibly and out-
wardly profess to be his subjects, and act outwardly as if they believed on him. But these
outward acts in themselves are not that religion and obedience, which Christ requires; nay,
of themselves, they have no religion in them; and Christ has nothing to do with them, but
as they are the fruits and expressions of the heart, as they are the language and index of the
mind and conscience, and outward declarations of the inward frame, tempers and acting,
of the soul. If they are not so, they are so far from having any religion in them, that they are
hateful to him, being only the visible resemblance, the pretence and feigning, of religion; i.e.
they are mockery, hypocrisy, falsehood, and lies; and belong not to the kingdom of Christ,
but of the devil.“—Let the reader now compare this with my gloss on the text.
Thus I have considered the various pans and principles of Mr. W.‘s scheme, which are
the foundations on which he builds all his superstructure, and the ground on which he
proceeds in all his reasonings, through his book; and many particulars in his answers and
arguments have been already considered.—Mr. W. says thus, (p. 135.a.) “I own, that at
present I have no more expectation to see the scheme which Mr. Edwards aims to establish,
defended upon Calvinistic principles, than the doctrine of transubstantiation.“ On which I
shall only say, it might perhaps be thought very impertinent in me, to tell my readers what
I do or what I do not expect, concerning his scheme. Every reader, that has reason enough
1965
SECTION IX. Public covenanting.