handed down.”35 For that holy and prudent man well knew that true piety admits no other
rule than that whatsoever things have been faithfully received from our fathers the same are
to be faithfully consigned to our children; and that it is our duty, not to lead religion
whither we would, but rather to follow religion whither it leads; and that it is the part of
Christian modesty and gravity not to hand down our own beliefs or observances to those
who come after us, but to preserve and keep what we have received from those who went
before us. What then was the issue of the whole matter? What but the usual and customary
one? Antiquity was retained, novelty was rejected.
[17.] But it may be, the cause of innovation at that time lacked patronage. On the con-
trary, it had in its favor such powerful talent, such copious eloquence, such a number of
partisans, so much resemblance to truth, such weighty support in Scripture (only interpreted
in a novel and perverse sense), that it seems to me that that whole conspiracy could not
possibly have been defeated, unless the sole cause of this extraordinary stir, the very novelty
of what was so undertaken, so defended, so belauded, had proved wanting to it. In the end,
what result, under God, had that same African Council or decree?36 None whatever. The
whole affair, as though a dream, a fable, a thing of no possible account, was annulled, can-
celled, and trodden underfoot.
[18.] And O marvellous revolution! The authors of this same doctrine are judged
Catholics, the followers heretics; the teachers are absolved, the disciples condemned; the
writers of the books will be children of the Kingdom, the defenders of them will have their
portion in Hell. For who is so demented as to doubt that that blessed light among all holy
bishops and martyrs, Cyprian, together with the rest of his colleagues, will reign with Christ;
or, who on the other hand so sacrilegious as to deny that the Donatists and those other pests,
who boast the authority of that council for their iteration of baptism, will be consigned to
eternal fire with the devil?37
35 Stephen’s letter has not come down to us, happily perhaps for his credit, judging by the terms in which
Cyprian speaks of it in the letter in which he quotes the passage in the text.—Ad Pompeian, Ep. 74.
36 The Council held under the presidency of Cyprian in 256. Its acts are contained in Cyprian’s works, Ed.
Fell. pp. 158, etc. An earlier council had been held in the same city in the beginning of the century under Agrip-
pinus. Both had affirmed the necessity of rebaptizing heretics, or, as they would rather have said, of baptizing
them. The controversy was set at rest by a decision of the council of Arles, in 314, which ordered, in its Eighth
Canon, that if the baptism had been administered in the name of the Trinity, converts should be admitted simply
by the imposition of hands that they might receive the Holy Ghost.
37 See Hooker’s reference to this passage.—Eccles. Poll. v. 62, § 9.
313
Chapter VI. The example of Pope Stephen in resisting the Iteration of B…