SECTION 5
James 2:14-26
FAITH, WITHOUT WORKS, IS DEAD
James 2:14-17
14 What doth it profit, my brethren,---We have had occasion to observe quite often in these notes that it was James' design to emphasize the practical aspects of Christianity in his Epistle, and to teach his readers that it is the doer and not the hearer alonp. who enjoys the approbation of God. It is from the eminently practical character of the Epistle that it has been styled "The Gospel of Common Sense." In the verses immediately preceding it was shown that one who loves his neighbor as himself will show mercy to his neighbor though the neighbor be poor and not rich; and, here it is demonstrated that where one is indifferent to the needs of those about him such is clear proof of the want of true faith on the part of the one exhibiting such indifference.
For centuries James 2:14-26, has been the occasion of much controversy; and, it was this passage which prompted Martin Luther to regard the Epistle of James with considerable contempt, and to describe it as "a right strawy one." Others, who entertain no doubts regarding the inspiration of the book and passage, have nevertheless engaged in much useless and vain speculation thereon in an effort to harmonize an alleged conflict of teaching between James and Paul! There are those who believe that Paul, in Romans 4:1-6, teaches that justification is by faith without works of any kind; and, inasmuch as James, in this passage (James 2:14-26), quite obviously affirms that there is no justification apart from works, it poses quite a problem for the advocates of the doctrine of salvation by faith only. Moreover, Paul, in Ephesians 2:8-9, wrote: "For by grace have ye been saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God; not of works that no man should glory." Yet, James asserted: "Was not Abraham our father justified by works, in that he offered up Isaac his son upon the altar? Thou seest that faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect." (James 2:21-22.)
It should be apparent to the most casual reader that Paul and James are discussing two different kinds of works in these passages. Paul refers to works which are excluded from God's plan to save; James discusses works which are included in it. Each writer gives the characteristics of the works under consideration. Those excluded, discussed by Paul, are works in which one might glory (exult in, boast of); the works included (mentioned by James, are those which perfect faith. Of the first category, works of which a man might boast and in which he might glory, are human, meritorious works, works of human achievement, works the design of which is to earn salvation. Were it possible for man to devise a plan by which he could save himself, he could dispense with grace, accomplish his own deliverance from sin, and glory in God's presence.
Such of course, is utterly impossible. All such works are excluded. The works included, and discussed by James, are the ccmunandments of the Lord, obedience to which is absolutely essential to salvation. ( 1 John 2:4; 2 Thessalonians 1:7-9.) Humble submission to the will of God as expressed in his commandments, far from involving works of the type excluded, demonstrate complete reliance upon God, and not upon one's self. Only those who seek to exclude all work, even the commandments of the Lord, such as baptism in water for the remission of sins (Mark 16:15-16; Acts 2:38), have any difficulty in harmonizing Paul and James ! Paul taught the necessity of obedience to the commands of Christ as plainly, positively and emphatically as did James. (Romans 6:3-4.)
The alleged difficulties in this section are not of the inspired writer's making, but stem from the erroneous view that salvation is by faith alone, before and without other acts of obedience. Because James teaches that faith, apart from works, is dead, the passage does indeed pose a serious problems for those who teach that "the doctrine of faith, and faith only, is a most wholesome doctrine, and very full of comfort." (Methodist Disciple, Art. 9.) We shall have occasion, in these notes, to observe some of the efforts put forth by denominational theologians to avoid the obvious difficulty which they face here.
if a man say he hath faith, but have not works? can that faith save him?--- Two questions are raised: (1) Of what profit is there to a man who says he has faith, but does not have works? (2) Can that faith save him? "Profit," is from ophelos, increase; and, as here used, denotes advantage, blessing, good, etc. What good is to be derived by the man who has faith but not works? Can that faith save him? It should be carefully noted that James does not minimize the importance of faith. The doctrine of salvation by faith is clearly and repeatedly taught in the New Testament. (Romans 5:1; 1 John 5:1; John 3:16; John 3:36.) In none of these passages, nor elsewhere in the Testament, is the doctrine of salvation by faith otuy taught. Inasmuch as faith is the great principle of salvation on the basis of which its possessor is led to do the will of God, it is often made to stand for all of the conditions of salvation,-indeed for the entire Christian system. (Galatians 3:23-29.) The faith that saves is of the type which expresses itself in obedience to the commandments of the Lord; and it produces a blessing only when it so does,-a proposition which Jam es proceeds to prove.
A man says, "I have faith, but not works." James asks, "Can that faith save him?" The statement is rhetorical; it is put in question form for emphasis. The Greek sentence is me dunatai he pis tis sosai auton, and is so constructed (with me) that a negative answer is expected. The meaning is, That faith cannot save him! Note that James does not deny the efficacy of faith. Under consideration is a special kind of faith. What kind is it?
That which is without works. James picks out this particular kind of faith and says that it cannot save. Note the use of the demonstrative that. That what? That faith! What kind of faith is that?
The kind of faith that is without works. What is affirmed of it? It cannot save. What cannot save? Faith without works. What works?
The commandments of the Lord! This is decisive of the matter in issue. It makes clear the fact that faith, apart from, and without works, is profitless, barren, vain and dead, all of which James later affirms. (Verses 17, 20, 26.)
It is noteworthy that the verbs in the statement, "If a man say he hath faith and have not works," are present active subjunctives, thus, "If one keeps on saying he has faith, but keeps on not having works .... " Mere profession, without obedience to God's commands, is worthless. Chapter eleven, of Hebrews, is Inspiration's Hall of Fame. There the wonderful worthies of the illustrious past are made to appear in demonstration of the tremendous faith and humble obedience which ever characterized them as they sought to discharge the will of God in their day. It will be observed that the mention of their faith is followed by a verb of action, thus evidencing the fact that faith blesses only when it leads its possessor to obedience. God has never blessed anybody, in any age or dispensation, because of faith, until the faith exhibited itself in action. Faith saves; but only when it prompts to faithful and unquestioning obedience to the will of God. Proof of this James demonstrates in the verses following.
15 If a brother or sister be naked and in lack of daily food,---In view of the fact that those to whom James wrote were disposed to treat with contempt the poor among them, and to show servile favoritism for the rich, it may well be that the writer, in this instance, brings forth an actual incident. It is, in any event, a practical demonstration of the principle that he is impressing in these verses; viz., that faith, apart from works (of obedience) is profitless, barren, vain, and dead. James, to illustrate his principle that faith, apart from work, cannot bless, introduces an instance of the most inexcusable kind. A "brother," or "sister," is (a) "naked," and (b) "in lack of daily food." "Naked," here does not mean utterly without clothing, but nearly so; i.e., without sufficient clothing. (Matthew 25:36; John 21:7; Acts 19:16.) "In lack of daily food," indicates that the person under consideration is in the greatest possible destitution, in a condition of want that would touch the hearts of all but the hardest. Under contemplation is "a brother," or "a sister." While these words do not require the conclusion that they were members of the body of Christ (See Acts 9:17, where Ananias addressed Saul of Tarsus, before he obeyed the gospel, as "Brother Saul . . ." because he was a brother Israelite, and compare Matthew 5:23, Acts 2:29; Acts 3:17, it is likely that they were Christians, although our obligation to assist the needy and destitute is not limited to those who are members of the church. Paul wrote to the churches of Galatia, and instructed them "to work that which is good toward all men, and especially toward them that are of the household of faith" (Galatians 1:1 ff; Galatians 6:10), in which instance it is absurd to assume that it is wrong for churches of Christ to do what Paul commanded the churches in Galatia to do.
16 and one of you say unto them, Go in peace, be ye warmed and filled;---The verbs of the first two clauses are quite significant, and make more vivid the lesson intended. In the first, (eipei de tis autois ex humon), the verb is an aorist active subjunctive, in effect, "Let us be done with this matter at oner.; in the second, (hupagete en eirenei), it is a present active imperative, "keep on going in peace!" This phrase translated, "Go in peace," was the usual Jewish expression of farewell. (Luke 7:50 8:48; Acts 16:36; 1 Samuel 1:17; 1 Samuel 20:42.) In the third clause, "Be ye warmed and filled," (thermainesthe kai chortazesthe), the verbs may be either middle or passive; if middle, the meaning is "Get yourselves warmed and filled"; if passive, "Be warmed and filled yourselves." The middle voice is the more probable in view of the context. It was James' design to show the heartlessness of the disposition which bids a sister or brother to go his way, and to shift for himself; and the middle more nearly conforms to this design. Far from assisting the destitute in their distress, empty words were substituted for good deeds. Those with insufficient clothing are bidden to "Warm yourselves!" Those in need of food to "Fill yourselves !" And, with a wave of the hand and a dismissal of all responsibility, the poor are told "Farewell! Be off.
Best wishes. Feed and fill your own selves."
and yet ye give them not the things needful to the body;---The "things needful to the body," include the food and clothing implied in the preceding statement. The "things" mentioned would not be limited to this, but would include whatever is essential to meet the needs of the persons under contemplation, such as medicine, professional attention, nursing care, and the like. The words, "Go in peace, be ye warmed and filled," are empty, meaningless gestures; warm words, resulting in icy rejection of duty and responsibility.
what doth it profit?---Put in question form for emphasis, the meaning is, There is no profit in such. One is not warmed by good wishes; one cannot fill an empty stomach with greetings. The application follows in the next verse.
17 Even so faith, if it have not works, is dead in itself.---Here the writer returns to the theme of verse 14 ("'What doth it profit, my brethren, if a man say he hath faith, but have not works? Can that faith save him?"). The verses which intervene are designed to illustrate the fact that there is no profit in faith without works. "Even so," means in like manner; that is. as there is no benefit whatsoever in good words, when not attended by deeds, neither is there any profit in faith, if it ''have not works . ... " The phrase "have not works," (ean me erga Pchei), is a condition of the third class, the verb being a present active subjunctive; i.e., "if it keep on not having works .... " There is no profit in faith which is without works.
It is evident that the "works" of which James writes are the commandments of the Lord. (James 2:20-22.) It is indeed such "works" which demonstrate faith. Our confidence (faith) in our physician is evidenced by our willingness to do what he says. In like manner, he who affects to believe in the Lord, yet refusrs to do what the Lord commands, or doing it. does so on other grounds, demonstrates that his faith is vain. fruitless, dead. James affirms that "faith, if it have not works, is dead in itself.·" · "In itself," is kath' heauten, of itself, according to itself, by the utter absence of "works." Because it is lacking in that which evidences life in faith (works). it is dead. being incomplete, partial. fragmentary; no more alive than a body from which the spirit has flown. As a dead body is lacking in that which gives it liie (the spirit). so faith, without works, is dead. being deficient in that which gives life to faith. It is dead, not only with reference to outward signs of life. it is dead in itself.
A rose bush, in the cold. dark days of winter exhibits no signs of life, but it is not dead in itself; when the warmth of lovely spring days falls upon it. it buds and blooms and flowers forth into life and beauty. Faith, without works, has no winter, and consequently, no flowering spnng.
The lesson is obvious. As one who is in need and hungry, cannot profit from kind words and fair speeches, neither is there any blessing in faith which does not prompt to faithful obedience of the Lord's commandments. We prove that our good wishes for others are genuine when we translate them into golden deeds oi mercy and good will ; and we prove our faith when we are obedient to the will of him whose word prompts to faith. We should be deeply impressed with the lesson which Jam es teaches here that faith, unattended by unquestioning obedience to the Lord's will is as worthless and vain as the expression of empty wis!-tes for the needy with no effort expended to relieve their distressed condition. There is no help for a sick, hungry family in pious platitudes, unaccompanied by assistance; and there is no blessing promised or salvation available to people on the basis of faith without works. We have earlier observed that the works under consideration are not the works of the law of Moses, or of human merit; but, the commandments of the Lord. Peter said, "Of a truth I perceive that God is no respecter of persons: but in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is acceptable to him." (Acts 10:34-35.) Righteousness is the keeping of God's commandments. (Psalms 119:172.)