the man who, though surrounded with abundance of worldly possessions, is, through the
insatiable eagerness wherewith he covets these, kept always in a state of want, which, to use
the words of your own authors, neither plenty nor scarcity can relieve. In the letter, however,
to which you reply, I did not say that those of your citizens who are enemies to the Church
were to be corrected by being reduced to that extremity of indigence in which the necessaries
of life are wanting, and to which succour is brought by that compassion of which you have
thought it incumbent on you to point out to me that it is professed by us in the whole plan
of those labours wherein we “support the poor, minister healing to the diseased, and apply
remedies to the bodies of those who are in pain;” albeit, even such extremity of want as this
would be more profitable than abundance of all things, if abused to the gratification of evil
passions. But far be it from me to think that those about whom we are treating should be
reduced to such destitution by the measures of coercion proposed.
Chap. II.
5. Though you did not consider it worth while to read my letter over when it was to be
answered, perhaps you have at least so far esteemed it as to preserve it, in order to its being
brought to you when you at any time might desire it and call for it; if this be the case, look
over it again, and mark carefully my words: you will assuredly find in it one thing to which,
in my opinion, you must admit that you have made no reply. For in that letter occur the
words which I now quote: “We do not desire to gratify our anger by vindictive retribution
for the past, but we are concerned to make provision in a truly merciful spirit for the future.
Now wicked men have something in respect to which they may be punished, and that by
Christians, in a merciful way, and so as to promote their own profit and well-being. For
they have these three things—life and health of the body, the means of supporting that life,
and the means and opportunities of living a wicked life. Let the two former remain untouched
in the possession of those who repent of their crime; this we desire, and this we spare no
pains to secure. But as to the third, if it please God to deal with it as a decaying or diseased
part, which must be removed with the pruning-knife, He will in such punishment prove
the greatness of his compassion.”2374 If you had read over these words of mine again, when
you were pleased to write your reply, you would have looked upon it rather as an unkind
insinuation than as a necessary duty to address to me a petition not only for deliverance
from death, but also for exemption from torture, on behalf of those regarding whom I said
that we wished to leave unimpaired their possession of bodily life and health. Neither was
there any ground for your apprehending our inflicting a life of indigence and of dependence
upon others for daily bread on those regarding whom I had said that we desired to secure
to them the second of the possessions named above, viz. the means of supporting life. But
as to their third possession, viz. the means and opportunities of living wickedly, that is to
2374 Letter CXI. 9. p. 379.
933
To Nectarius