3. Now when Arius and his fellows made these
assertions, and shamelessly avowed them, we being assembled with the
Bishops of Egypt and Libya, nearly a hundred in number, anathematized
both them and their followers. But Eusebius and his fellows admitted
them to communion, being desirous to mingle falsehood with the truth,
and impiety with piety. But they will not be able to do so, for the
truth must prevail; neither is there any “communion of light with
darkness,” nor any “concord of Christ with Belial (2 Cor. vi. 14.) κοινωνία
φωτί. This is quoted Alex.
ap. Theod. H. E. i. 3. p. 738; by S. Athan. in Letter 47.
It seems to have been a received text in the controversy, as the
Sardican Council uses it, Apol Ar. 49, and S. Athan. seems to
put it into the mouth of St. Anthony, Vit. Ant. 69..” For who ever heard such assertions
before τίς γὰρ
ἤκουσε. Ep.
Æg. §7 init. Letter 59. §2 init. Orat.
i. 8. Apol. contr. Ar. 85 init. Hist. Ar. §46 init.
§73 init. §74 init. ad Serap. iv. 2 init.? or who that hears them now is not astonished
and does not stop his ears lest they should be defiled with such
language? Who that has heard the words of John, “In the beginning
was the Word John i. 1.,” will not denounce the saying of
these men, that “there was a time when He was not?” Or who
that has heard in the Gospel, “the Only-begotten Son,” and
“by Him were all things made John i. 3, 14.,” will not
detest their declaration that He is “one of the things that were
made.” For how can He be one of those things which were made by
Himself? or how can He be the Only-begotten, when, according to them,
He is counted as one among the rest, since He is Himself a creature and
a work? And how can He be “made of things that were not,”
when the Father saith, “My heart hath uttered a good Word,”
and “Out of the womb I have begotten Thee before the morning
star Ps. xlv. 1. and cx.
3.?” Or again, how is He “unlike in
substance to the Father,” seeing He is the perfect
“image” and “brightness Heb. i. 3.” of the Father, and that He saith,
“He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father (Joh. xiv. 9, 10; x. 29.) On the concurrence of
these three texts in Athan. (though other writers use them too, and
Alex. ap. Theod. has two of them), vid. note on Orat. i.
34.?” And if the Son is the
“Word” and “Wisdom” of God, how was there
“a time when He was not?” It is the same as if they should
say that God was once without Word and without Wisdom ἄλογον καὶ
ἄσοφον τὸν
θεόν. de Decr.
§15. Orat. i. §19. Ap. Fug. 27. note, notes on
Or. i. 19, de. Decr. 15, note 6..
And how is He “subject to change and variation,” Who says,
by Himself, “I am in the Father, and the Father in Me (Joh. xiv. 9, 10; x. 29.) On the concurrence of
these three texts in Athan. (though other writers use them too, and
Alex. ap. Theod. has two of them), vid. note on Orat. i.
34.,” and “I and the Father are One (Joh. xiv. 9, 10; x. 29.) On the concurrence of
these three texts in Athan. (though other writers use them too, and
Alex. ap. Theod. has two of them), vid. note on Orat. i.
34.;” and by the Prophet, “Behold Me,
for I am, and I change not (Mal. iii. 6.) This text is thus applied by Athan. Orat. i. 30.
ii. 10. In the first of these passages he uses the same apology, nearly
in the same words, which is contained in the text.?” For although
one may refer this expression to the Father, yet it may now be more
aptly spoken of the Word, viz., that though He has been made man, He
has not changed; but as the Apostle has said, “Jesus Christ is
the same yesterday, to-day, and for ever.” And who can have
persuaded them to say, that He was made for us, whereas Paul writes,
“for Whom are all things, and by Whom are all things Heb. xiii. 8; ii.
10.?”