cxvii
Mr. Edwards thought proper to proceed according to his proposal, and accordingly preached
a number of sermons, till he had finished what he had to say on the subject. These lectures
were very thinly attended by his own people; but great numbers of strangers from the
neighbouring towns attended them, so many as to make above half the congregation. This
was in February and March, 1750.
The calling of a decisive council, to determine the matter of difference, was now more
particularly attended to on both sides. Mr. Edwards had before this insisted, from time to
time, that they were by no means ripe for such a procedure; as they had not yet given him
a fair hearing, whereby perhaps the need of such a council would be superseded. He observed,
“That it was exceedingly unbecoming to manage religious affairs of the greatest importance
in a ferment and tumult, which ought to be managed with great solemnity, deep humiliation,
submission to the awful frowns of Heaven, humble dependence on God, with fervent prayer
and supplication to him: that therefore for them to go about such an affair as they did, would
be greatly to the dishonour of God and religion; a way in which a people cannot expect a
blessing.” Thus having used all means to bring them to a calm and charitable temper without
effect, he consented that a decisive council should be called without any further delay.
But a difficulty attended the choice of a council, which was for some time insuperable.
It was agreed, that the council should be mutually chosen, one half by the pastor, and the
other half by the church, but the people insisted upon it, that he should be confined to the
county for his choice. Mr. Edwards thought this an unreasonable restraint upon him, as it
was known that the ministers and churches in that county were almost universally against
him in the controversy. He indeed did not suppose that the business of the proposed council
would be to determine whether his opinion was right or not; but whether any possible way
could be devised for an accommodation between pastor and people, and to use their wisdom
and endeavour in order to effect it. And if they found this impracticable, they must determine,
whether what ought in justice to be done had already actually been attempted, so that there
was nothing further to be demanded by either of the parties concerned, before a separation
should take place. And if he was dismissed by them, it would be their business to set forth
to the world in what manner, and for what cause, he was dismissed: all which were matters
of great importance to him, and required upright and impartial judges. Now considering
the great influence a difference in religious opinions has to prejudice men one against an-
other, and the close connexion of the point, in which most of the ministers and churches
in the county differed from him, with the matter to be judged of, he did not think they could
be reasonably looked upon so impartial judges, as that the matter ought to be left wholly to
them. Besides, he thought that the case, being so new and extraordinary, required the ablest
judges in the land. For these, and some other reasons which he offered, he insisted upon
liberty to go out of the county, for those members of the proposed council in which he was
to have a choice. In this the people strenuously and obstinately opposed him. At length they
239
CHAPTER XVI. Commencement of difficulties at Northampton