11. At his suggestion
then ye have maintained and ye think, that ‘there was once when
the Son was not;’ this is the first cloke of your views of
doctrine which has to be stripped off. Say then what was once when the
Son was not, O slanderous and irreligious men Athan. observes that this formula of the Arians is a mere evasion
to escape using the word ‘time.’ vid. also Cyril.
Thesaur. iv. pp. 19, 20. Else let them
explain,—‘There was,’ what ‘when the Son
was not?’ or what was before the Son? since He Himself was
before all times and ages, which He created, de Decr. 18, note
5. Thus, if ‘when’ be a word of time, He it is who
was ‘when’ He was not, which is absurd. Did
they mean, however, that it was the Father who ‘was’ before
the Son? This was true, if ‘before’ was taken, not to imply
time, but origination or beginning. And in this sense the first verse
of S. John’s Gospel may be interpreted ‘In the
Beginning,’ or Origin, i.e. in the Father ‘was the
Word.’ Thus Athan. himself understands that text, Orat.
iv. §1. vid. also Orat. iii. §9; Nyssen. contr.
Eunom. iii. p. 106; Cyril. Thesaur. 32. p. 312.?
If ye say the Father, your blasphemy is but greater; for it is impious
to say that He was ‘once,’ or to signify Him by the word
‘once.’ For He is ever, and is now, and as the Son is, so
is He, and is Himself He that is, and Father of the Son. But if ye say
that the Son was once, when He Himself was not, the answer is foolish
and unmeaning. For how could He both be and not be? In this difficulty,
you can but answer, that there was a time when the Word was not; for
your very adverb ‘once’ naturally signifies this. And your
other, ‘The Son was not before His generation,’ is
equivalent to saying, ‘There was once when He was not,’ for
both the one and the other signify that there is a time before the
Word. Whence then this your discovery? Why do ye, as ‘the
heathen, rage, and imagine vain phrases against the Lord Ps. ii. 1. and against His Christ?’ for no holy
Scripture has used such language of the Saviour, but rather
‘always’ and ‘eternal’ and ‘coexistent
always with the Father.’ For, ‘In the beginning was the
Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God John i. 1..’ And in the Apocalypse he thus
speaks Rev. i. 4. τάδε
λέγει. [On
λέγει, &c., in citations, see Lightf. on Gal. iii. 16, Winer,
Gram. §58, 9 γ, Grimm-Thayer, s.v. II. 1.
e.]; ‘Who is and who was and who is
to come.’ Now who can rob ‘who is’ and ‘who
was’ of eternity? This too in confutation of the Jews hath Paul
written in his Epistle to the Romans, ‘Of whom as concerning the
flesh is Christ, who is over all, God blessed for ever Rom. ix. 5.;’ while silencing the Greeks, he has
said, ‘The visible things of Him from the creation of the world
are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even
His eternal Power and Godhead Ib. i. 20.;’ and what
the Power of God is, he teaches us elsewhere himself, ‘Christ the
Power of God and the Wisdom of God 1 Cor. i. 24. Athan. has so
interpreted this text supr. de Decr. 15. It was either a
received interpretation, or had been adduced at Nicæa, for
Asterius had some years before these Discourses replied to it, vid.
de Syn. 18, and Orat. ii. §37..’ Surely
in these words he does not designate the Father, as ye often whisper
one to another, affirming that the Father is ‘His eternal
power.’ This is not so; for he says not, ‘God Himself is
the power,’ but ‘His is the power.’ Very plain is it
to all that ‘His’ is not ‘He;’ yet not
something alien but rather proper to Him. Study too the context and
‘turn to the Lord;’ now ‘the Lord is that Spirit 2 Cor. iii. 16,
17.
S. Athanasius observes, Serap. i. 4–7, that the Holy Ghost
is never in Scripture called simply ‘Spirit’ without the
addition ‘of God’ or ‘of the Father’ or
‘from Me’ or of the article, or of ‘Holy,’ or
‘Comforter,’ or ‘of truth,’ or unless He has
been spoken of just before. Accordingly this text is understood of the
third Person in the Holy Trinity by Origen, contr. Cels. vi. 70;
Basil de Sp. S. n. 32; Pseudo-Athan. de comm. ess. 6. On
the other hand, the word πνεῦμα,
‘Spirit, is used more or less distinctly for our Lord’s
Divine Nature whether in itself or as incarnate, in Rom. i. 4, 1 Cor. xv. 45,
1 Tim. iii. 16, Hebr. ix. 14, 1 Pet. iii. 18, John vi. 63, &c. [But cf.
also Milligan Resurr. 238 sq.] Indeed the early Fathers speak as
if the ‘Holy Spirit,’ which came down upon S. Mary might be
considered the Word. E.g. Tertullian against the Valentinians,
‘If the Spirit of God did not descend into the womb “to
partake in flesh from the womb,” why did He descend at
all?’ de Carn. Chr. 19. vid. also ibid. 5 and 14.
contr. Prax. 26, Just. Apol. i. 33. Iren.
Hær. v. 1. Cypr. Idol Van. 6. Lactant.
Instit. iv. 12. vid. also Hilar. Trin. ii. 27;
Athan. λόγος ἐν τῷ
πνεύματι
ἔπλαττε τὸ
σῶμα. Serap. i. 31
fin. ἐν τῷ λόγῳ
ἦν τὸ
πνεῦμα ibid.
iii. 6. And more distinctly even as late as S. Maximus, αὐτὸν
ἀντὶ σπορᾶς
συλλαβοῦσα
τὸν λόγον,
κεκύηκε, t.
2. p. 309. The earliest ecclesiastical authorities are S. Ignatius
ad Smyrn. init. and S. Hermas (even though his date were a.d. 150), who also says plainly: Filius autem
Spiritus Sanctus est. Sim. v. 5, 2, cf. ix. 1. The same use of
‘Spirit’ for the Word or Godhead of the Word, is also found
in Tatian. adv. Græc. 7. Athenag. Leg. 10. Theoph.
ad Autol. ii. 10. Iren. Hær. iv. 36. Tertull.
Apol. 23. Lact. Inst. iv. 6, 8. Hilar. Trin. ix.
3, and 14. Eustath. apud Theod. Eran. iii. p. 235. Athan.
contr. Apoll. i. 8. Apollinar. ap. Theod. Eran. i.
p. 71, and the Apollinarists passim. Greg. Naz. Ep. 101.
ad Cledon. p. 85. Ambros. Incarn. 63. Severian. ap.
Theod. Eran. ii. p. 167. Vid. Grot. ad Marc. ii. 8; Bull,
Def. F. N. i. 2, §5; Coustant. Præf. in Hilar.
57, &c. Montfaucon in Athan. Serap. iv. 19. [see also
Tertullian, de Orat. init.];’and you will see that it is the Son
who is signified.