This work, which is also now lost, is mentioned by no other Father
except Jerome, who puts it first in his list of Theophilus’
writings, but does not characterize it in any way, though he says it
was extant in his time. Irenæus, in four passages of his great
work, exhibits striking parallels to Bk. II. chap. 25 of
Theophilus’ ad Autol., which have led to the assumption
that he knew the latter work. Harnack, however, on account of the
shortness of time which elapsed between the composition of the ad
Autol. and Irenæus’ work, and also on account of the
nature of the resemblances between the parallel passages, thinks it
improbable that Irenæus used the ad Autol., and concludes
that he was acquainted rather with Theophilus’ work against
Marcion, a conclusion which accords best with the facts known to
us.