Chapter XI.
And since, as you dare not deny that these deities of
yours once were men, you have taken it on you to assert that they were
made gods after their decease, let us consider what necessity there was
for this. In the first place, you must concede the existence of one
higher God—a certain wholesale dealer in divinity, who has made
gods of men. For they could neither have assumed a divinity which
was not theirs, nor could any but one himself possessing it have
conferred it on them. If there was no one to make gods, it is vain to
dream of gods being made when thus you have no god-maker. Most
certainly, if they could have deified themselves, with a higher state
at their command, they never would have been men. If, then, there be
one who is able to make gods, I turn back to an examination of any
reason there may be for making gods at all; and I find no other reason
than this, that the great God has need of their ministrations and aids
in performing the offices of Deity. But first it is an unworthy idea
that He should need the help of a man, and in fact a dead man, when, if
He was to be in want of this assistance from the dead, He might more
fittingly have created some one a god at the beginning. Nor do I
see any place for his action. For this entire
world-mass—whether self-existent and uncreated, as Pythagoras
maintains, or brought into being by a creator’s hands, as Plato
holds—was manifestly, once for all in its original construction,
disposed, and furnished, and ordered, and supplied with a government of
perfect wisdom. That cannot be imperfect which has made all perfect.
There was nothing waiting on for Saturn and his race to do. Men will
make fools of themselves if they refuse to believe that from the very
first rain poured down from the sky, and stars gleamed, and light
shone, and thunders roared, and Jove himself dreaded the lightnings you
put in his hands; that in like manner before Bacchus, and Ceres, and
Minerva, nay before the first man, whoever that was, every kind of
fruit burst forth plentifully from the bosom of the earth, for nothing
provided for the support and sustenance of man could be introduced
after his entrance on the stage of being. Accordingly, these
necessaries of life are said to have been discovered, not
created. But the thing you discover existed before; and that
which had a pre-existence must be regarded as belonging not to him who
discovered it, but to him who made it, for of course it had a being
before it could be found. But if, on account of his being the
discoverer of the vine, Bacchus is raised to godship, Lucullus, who
first introduced the cherry from Pontus into Italy, has not been fairly
dealt with; for as the discoverer of a new fruit, he has not, as though
he were its creator, been awarded divine honours. Wherefore, if
the universe existed from the beginning, thoroughly furnished with its
system working under certain laws for the performance of its functions,
there is, in this respect, an entire absence of all reason for electing
humanity to divinity; for the positions and powers which you have
assigned to your deities have been from the beginning precisely what
they would have been, although you had never deified them. But
you turn to another reason, telling us that the conferring
of deity was a way of rewarding worth. And
hence you grant, I conclude, that the god-making God is of transcendent
righteousness,—one who will neither rashly, improperly, nor
needlessly bestow a reward so great. I would have you then consider
whether the merits of your deities are of a kind to have raised them to
the heavens, and not rather to have sunk them down into lowest depths
of Tartarus,—the place which you regard, with many, as the
prison-house of infernal punishments. For into this dread place are
wont to be cast all who offend against filial piety, and such as are
guilty of incest with sisters, and seducers of wives, and ravishers of
virgins, and boy-polluters, and men of furious tempers, and murderers,
and thieves, and deceivers; all, in short, who tread in the footsteps
of your gods, not one of whom you can prove free from crime or vice,
save by denying that they had ever a human existence. But as you cannot
deny that, you have those foul blots also as an added reason for not
believing that they were made gods afterwards. For if you rule for the
very purpose of punishing such deeds; if every virtuous man among you
rejects all correspondence, converse, and intimacy with the wicked and
base, while, on the other hand, the high God has taken up their mates
to a share of His majesty, on what ground is it that you thus condemn
those whose fellow-actors you adore? Your goodness is an affront in the
heavens. Deify your vilest criminals, if you would please your gods.
You honour them by giving divine honours to their fellows. But to say
no more about a way of acting so unworthy, there have been men
virtuous, and pure, and good. Yet how many of these nobler men you have
left in the regions of doom! as Socrates, so renowned for his wisdom,
Aristides for his justice, Themistocles for his warlike genius,
Alexander for his sublimity of soul, Polycrates for his good fortune,
Crœsus for his wealth, Demosthenes for his eloquence. Which of
these gods of yours is more remarkable for gravity and wisdom than
Cato, more just and warlike than Scipio? which of them more magnanimous
than Pompey, more prosperous than Sylla, of greater wealth than
Crassus, more eloquent than Tullius? How much better it would have been
for the God Supreme to have waited that He might have taken such men as
these to be His heavenly associates, prescient as He must have surely
been of their worthier character! He was in a hurry, I suppose, and
straightway shut heaven’s gates; and now He must surely feel
ashamed at these worthies murmuring over their lot in the regions
below.