The person, however, who first brought the poor
recluse’s heretical statements prominently into notice was much
more reckless and intemperate in his language. This was Eusebius,
bishop of Dorylæum, who took the opportunity of a local synod held
in Constantinople under the presidency of the gentle Flavian, in
November, 448, for other business, to petition against his former
friend and ally as a blasphemer and a madman. The synod, after
expostulating with the accuser for his violence, at last reluctantly
consented to summon Eutyches to an account. The summons was at
least twice repeated and disobeyed under the pretext first that he
might not leave the monastery, then that he was ill. At last
Eutyches yielded, and appeared accompanied by a crowd of monks and
soldiers and by Florentius, a patrician for whom the weak Emperor
(Theodosius II.) had been influenced by the eunuch Chrysaphius,
Eutyches’ godson, to demand a seat at the council. After a
long conversation, in which Eutyches tried to evade a definite
statement, he was at last forced to confess that our Lord was of two natures before the union, but that after
the union there was but one nature (see Letter XXVIII. (Tome), chap.
vi.). As he persisted in maintaining this position, he was
condemned and thrust out of the priesthood and Church-communion.
During the reading of the condemnation and the breaking up of the
conclave, Eutyches is alleged to have told Florentius that he appealed
to the bishops of Rome, Alexandria, and Jerusalem. Flavian, as
president of the council, thought it his duty to acquaint the bishops
of Rome and other Sees of the first rank with what had taken
place. For some unknown reason his letter to Leo was delayed, and
the appeal of Eutyches and a letter from the Emperor was the first
information that he received. As might be expected from
Leo’s conception of his office, he was much incensed at this
apparent neglect, and wrote to the Emperor explaining his ignorance of
the facts, and to
Flavian, complaining of being kept in
ignorance, and prima facie of Eutyches’ treatment.
Meanwhile the delayed epistle arrived from Flavian, and the account
given was enough to satisfy Leo, who thereupon (May, 449) replied
briefly expressing his approval and promising a fuller treatment of the
question. This promise was fulfilled next month in the shape of
the world-famous “Tome,” which forms Letter XXVIII. in the
Leonine collection. The proper significance of this document is
well expressed by Mr. Gore Leo the Great, p. 53
(S.P.C.K.): this writer should also be consulted (pp. 53 to 70),
on the merits and importance of the Eutychian controversy
generally.: it is, he says,
“still more remarkable for its contents than for the
circumstances which produced it,” though “in itself it is a
sign of the times: for here we have a Latin bishop, ignorant of
Greek, defining the faith for Greek-speaking bishops, in view of
certain false opinions of Oriental origin.” Without
reviewing in detail the further correspondence that Leo carried on with
the various civil and ecclesiastical authorities at Constantinople
(among them being the influential and orthodox Pulcheria the
Emperor’s sister), we pass on to the events connected with the
second council of Ephesus. Through the influence of Chrysaphius,
as we have already seen, the Emperor was all along on the side of
Eutyches, and it was apparently at his instigation and in spite of
Leo’s guarded dissuasion that the council was now convened and
met in August, 449. The bishop of Rome excused himself from
personal attendance on the score of pressing business at home, and sent
three legates with instructions to represent his views, viz. Julius,
bishop of Puteoli, Renatus, a presbyter, and Hilary, a deacon, together
with Dulcitius, a notary Of these Renatus is said
to have died at Delos on the way, and Hilary is the future pope of that
name. Julius of Puteoli must be carefully distinguished from
Julian of Cos, who was also a confidant of Leo’s.. They started
about the middle of June, and the Synod opened on the 8th of August, in
the church of the B.V.M. By the Emperor’s order Dioscorus,
patriarch of Alexandria, was president, Leo’s chief
representative sat next him, and Flavian was placed only 5th, the
bishop of Antioch and Jerusalem being set above him: 130 bishops
in all were admitted, those who had condemned Eutyches being
excluded. Owing partly to the presence of the soldiery and a
number of turbulent monks under the Syrian archimandrite Barsubas, the
proceedings soon became riotous and disorderly. The
“Tome” was not read at all, though that was the purpose of
its composition. Eutyches was admitted to make his defence, which
was received as completely satisfactory. The acts of the Synod of
Constantinople on being read excited great indignation. Amid
tremendous uproar Eutyches was formally restored to communion and his
former position, and the president pronounced deposition upon Flavian
and Eusebius. Flavian appealed, and Hilary What happened to Julius
and Dulcitius is not known, though Leo does not express any disapproval
of their action.,
after uttering a monosyllabic protest,
“contradicitur,” managed to make good his
escape and carry the lamentable tidings to his anxiously-expectant
chief at Rome. The other bishops all more or less reluctantly
subscribed the restoration of Eutyches and the deposition of Flavian
and Eusebius. The end of Flavian is variously recorded, but the
most accurate version appears to be that amid many blows and rough
usage he was cast into prison, then driven into exile, and that within
a few days he died of the bodily and mental injuries he had received at
Epypa, a village in Lydia. These calamitous proceedings Leo
afterwards stigmatized as Latrocinium (brigandage), and the
council is generally known as the Robber council of Ephesus.