In point of literary value as poems, a high place cannot be claimed for these Hymns. Some of them indeed have much
of the devotional fervor, and not a little of the human pathos, of the
Psalms of David: others show something of the antithetic point
and epigrammatic terseness of the Proverbs of Solomon. Yet the
devout aspirations and confessions of the poet are too often forced and
artificial in their utterance; in his funeral dirges we seem here and
there to detect the false note of the professional mourner in the
effort to exhaust all possible topics of grief; in all his poems he
tends to prolong the series of his parallelisms to a wearisome length
and with an iteration that, though laboriously varied, is
tedious,—an iteration that has no precedent in the poetry of the
Old Testament, save in one or two of the latest Psalms, such as the
CXXXVIth with its recurring burden
“For His mercy endureth for ever,” or the CXIXth with its artificial arrangement (often
emulated in Syriac Hymnody) by which each of the twenty-two letters of
the alphabet in turn is made to head each one of eight consecutive
verses in praise of the Law of the Lord. On the whole, it must be
admitted that the greater qualities of poetry, such as abound
everywhere in nearly every writer of the Hebrew Scriptures,—of
truth in rendering the inmost feelings of man’s heart in words of
absolute simplicity, of aspiration that rises without effort to the
highest things of God—to these Ephraim’s Hymns have no
claim.