THE DIALOGUE AGAINST THE LUCIFERIANS. 323
Arian and afterwards invoke the Holy Ghost,
ought either to baptize him, because without
the Holy Ghost he could not be baptized, or,
if he was baptized in the Spirit, you must not
invoke the Holy Ghost for your convert who
received Him at the time of baptism.
7. L. Pray tell me, have you not read J in the Acts of the Apostles that those who
had already been baptized by John, on their
saying in reply to the Apostles' question that they had not even heard what the Holy Ghost
was, afterwards obtained the Holy Ghost ?
Whence it is clear that it is possible to be
baptized, and yet not to have the Holy Ghost. O. I do not think that those who form our
audience are so ignorant of the sacred books
that many words are needed to settle this little
question. But before I say anything in sup-
port of my assertion, listen while I point out
what confusion, upon your view, is introduced
into Scripture. What do we mean by saying
that John in his baptism could not give the
Holy Spirit to others, yet gave him to Christ ?
And who is that John ? a " The voice of one crying in the wilderness, Make ye ready the
way of the Lord, make his paths straight.". He
who used to say, * " Behold the Lamb of God,
which taketh away the sins of the world " : I
say too little, he who from his mother's womb
cried out, 4 " And whence is this to me that the
mother of my Lord should come unto me," did he not give the Holy Ghost ? And did
6 Ananias give him to Paul ? It perhaps looks like boldness in me to prefer him to all other
men. Hear then the words of our Lord,
8 " Among them that are born of women there hath not arisen a greater than John the Bap-
tist." For no prophet had the good fortune both to announce the coming of Christ, and to
point Him out with the finger. And what
necessity is there for me to dwell upon the
praises of so illustrious a man when God the
Father even calls him an angel ? ' " Behold, I send my messenger (angel) before thy face,
who shall prepare thy way before thee." He must have been an angel who after lodging in
his mother's womb at once began to frequent the desert wilds, and while still an infant
played with serpents ; who, when his eyes had
once gazed on Christ thought nothing else
worth looking at ; who exercised his voice,
worthy of a messenger of God, in the words of
the Lord, which are sweeter than honey and
the honey-comb. And, to delay my question
no further, thus it behooved " the Forerunner of the Lord to grow up. Now is it possible that a man of such character and renown did
' Xix. 3.
4 Luke i. 43. * Matt. xi. it. * Is. xl. 3: Matt. iii. 3. 1 John i. 29. * Acts ix. 17. Matt. xi. 10. man. AI. II. • matt. XI. 10.
• We venture to read ' decebat ' instead of ' dicebat.' Other
ise, we may render ' Thus (the Scripture) said that,' etc.
not give the Holy Ghost, while Cornelius the
centurion received Him before baptism ? Tell
me, pray, why could he not give Him ? You
don't know ? Then listen to the teaching of Scripture : the baptism of John did not so
much consist in the forgiveness of sins as in
being a baptism of repentance for the remission
of sins, that is, for a future remission, which was
to follow through the sanctification of Christ.
For it is written, * " John came, who baptized in the wilderness, and preached the baptism of
repentance unto remission of sins." And soon
after, * " And they were baptized of him in the
river Jordan, confessing their sins." For as he himself preceded Christ as His forerunner,
so also his baptism was the prelude to the
Lord's baptism. 3 " He that is of the earth,"
he said, " speaketh of the earth ; he that
cometh from heaven is above all." And again,
4 " I indeed baptize you with water, he shall
baptize you with the Holy Ghost." But if John, as he himself confessed, did not baptize
with the Spirit, it follows that he did not for-
give sins either, for no man has his sins remit-
ted without the Holy Ghost. *" Or if you con- tentiously argue that, because the baptism of
John was from heaven, therefore sins were for-
given by it, show me what more there is for us
to get in Christ's baptism. Because it for- gives sins, it releases from Gehenna. Because
it releases from Gehenna, it is perfect. But
no baptism can be called perfect except that
which depends on the cross and resurrection
of Christ. Thus, although John himself said,
6 " He must increase, but I must decrease," in your perverse scrupulosity you give more
than is due to the baptism of the servant, and
destroy that of the master to which you leave no more than to the other. What is the drift
of your assertion ? Just this— it does not
strike you as strange that those who had
been baptized by John, should afterwards by
the laying on of hands receive the Holy Ghost,
although it is evident that they did not obtain
even remission of sins apart from the faith
which was to follow. But you who receive a
person baptized by the Arians and allow him
:o have perfect baptism, after that admission
do you invoke the Holy Ghost as if this were
still some slight defect, whereas there is no
baptism of Christ without the Holy Ghost ?
But I have wandered too far, and when I might
have met my opponent face to face and repelled
tiis attack, I have only thrown a few light darts
from a distance. The baptism of John was so
"ar imperfect that it is plain they who had been Daptized by him were afterwards baptized with
the baptism of Christ. For thus the history
relates, ' " And it came to pass that while 1 Mark i. 4.
4 Matt. iii. n.
* Mark i. 5.
4 John iii. 30.
1 John iii. 31. • Acts xix. i, sqq.