vaE. 33-35. sr. MAsTnEW. 461
sin,but he who by good actionshas merited the same in
thislife.
33. Eithermake the tree good, and hisfruitgood;
or elsemake the treecorrupt,and hisfruitcorrupt:
forthetreeisknown by hisfruit.
34. 0 generationof vipers,how can ye,being evil,
speak good things? forout of the abundanceof the
heartthe mouth speaketh.
35. A good man out of the good treasureof the
heart bringeth forth good things: and an evil man
out of the eviltreasurebringethforthevilthings.
Cmns. After His former answers He here again refutesChrys...
them in another manner. This He does not in orderto do Hm‘ xh“
away theircharges againstHimself,but desiringto amend
them, saying,Either make the treegood and hisfruitgood,
or make the treecorrupt,and hisfruit corrupt. As much
as to say,None of you has saidthat it is an evilthing for
a man to be deliveredfrom daemons. But becausethey did
not speak evilof the works,but saidthat it was the Devil
thatwrought them, He shews thatthischarge iscontraryto
the common senseof things,and human conceptions. And
to invent such charges can only proceed from unbounded
impudence. JEROMn. Thus He holds them in a syllogism
which the Greeks call‘Aphycton,’the unavoidable;which
shuts in the person questionedon both sides,and presses
him with eitherhorn. If,He saith,the Devil be evil,he
cannot do good works ; so thatifthe works you seebe good,
itfollowsthatthe Devil was not the agent thereof. For it
cannot be that good should come of evil,or evilof good.
Cnmrs. F or the discerningof a tree is done by itsfruits,
not the fruitsby the tree. A treeis known by itsfruits.
For though the tree is the cause of the fruit,yet the fruit
isthe evidenceof the tree. But ye do the verycontrary,
having no faultto allegeagainstthe works,ye pass a sen
tenceof evilagainstthe tree,saying thatI have a daemon.
Hu./mY. Thus did He at that present refutethe Jews, who