330 INSTITUTES OF THE BOOK II.
been regenerated, and so had made no ordinary progress in
true piety, he confesses that he stood in need of direction
every moment, in order that he might not decline from the
knowledge with which he had been endued. Hence, he else
where prays for a renewal of a right spirit, which he had lost
by his sin,1 (Ps. li. 12.) For that which God gave at first,
while temporarily withdrawn, it is equally his province to re
store.
26. We must now examine the wiljj. on which the question
of freedom principally turns, the power of choice belonging
to it rather than the intellect, as we have already seen,
(supra, sect. 4.) And at the outset, to guard against its
being thought that the doctrine taught by philosophers, and
generally received, viz., that all things by natural instinct
have a desire of good, is any proof of the rectitude of the
human will, — let us observe, that the power of free will is
not to be considered in any of those desires which proceed
more from instinct than mental deliberation. Even the
schoolmen admit, ( Thomas, Part I., Quasi. 83, art. 3,) that
there is no act of free will, unless when reason looks at oppo-
sites. By this they mean, that the things desired must
be such as may be made the object of choice, and that to
pave the way for choice, deliberation must precede. And,
undoubtedly, if you attend to what this natural desire of good
in man is, you will find that it is common to him with the
brutes. They, too, desire what is good ; and when any
semblance of good capable of moving the sense appears, they
follow after it. Here, however, man does not, in accord
ance with the excellence of his immortal nature, rationally
choose, and studiously pursue, what is truly for his good.
He does not admit reason to his counsel, nor exert his
intellect ; but without reason, without counsel, follows the
bent of his nature like the lower animals. The question
of freedom, therefore, has nothing to do with the fact of
man's being led by natural instinct to desire good. The
question is, Does man, after determining by right reason
what is good, choose what he thus knows, and pursue
1 Calvin, in his Commentary on the passage, says, " Lost in part or ap
pearance, or deserved to lose."