Section IV.
It Is Agreeable To Common sense, And The Natural Notions of Mankind, To Suppose
Moral Necessity To Be Consistent With Praise And Blame, Reward And Punishment.
Whether the reasons that have been given, why it appears difficult to some persons
to reconcile with common sense the praising or blaming, rewarding or punishing those
things which are morally necessary, are thought satisfactory, or not; yet it most
evidently appears, by the following things, that if this matter be rightly understood,
setting aside all delusion arising from the impropriety and ambiguity of terms,
this is not at all inconsistent with the natural apprehensions of mankind, and that
sense of things which is found every where in the common people, who are furthest
from having their thoughts perverted from their natural channel, by metaphysical
and philosophical subtleties; but, on the contrary, altogether agreeable to, and
the very voice and dictate of, this natural and vulgar sense.
1. This will appear, if we consider what
the vulgar notion of blameworthiness is. The idea which the common people, through
all ages and nations, have of faultiness, I suppose to be plainly this; a person’s
being or doing wrong, with his own will and pleasure; containing these two things:
1. His doing wrong when he does as he pleases:
2. His pleasures being wrong.
Or, in other words, perhaps more intelligibly
expressing their notion, a person’s having his heart wrong; and doing wrong from
his heart. And this is the sum total of the matter.
The common people do not ascend up in their
reflections and abstractions to the metaphysical sources, relations, and dependencies
of things, in order to form their notion of faultiness or blameworthiness. They
do not wait till they have decided by their refinings, what first determines the
will; whether it be determined by something extrinsic or intrinsic; whether volition
determines volition, or whether the understanding determines the will; whether there
be any such thing as metaphysicians mean by contingence (if they have any meaning);
whether there be a sort of a strange, unaccountable sovereignty in the will, in
the exercise of which, by its own sovereign acts, it brings to pass all its own
sovereign acts. They do not take any part of their notion of fault or blame from
the resolution of any such question. If this were the case, there are multitudes,
yea, the far greater part of mankind, nine hundred and ninety-nine out of a thousand,
would live and die without having any such notion as that of fault ever entering
into their heads, or without so much as one having any conception that any body
was to be either blamed or commended for any thing. To be sure it would be a long
time before men came to have such notions. Whereas it is manifest, they are some
of the first notions that appear in children; who discover, as soon as they can
think, or speak, or act at all as rational creatures, a sense of desert. And certainly,
in forming their notion of it, they make no use of metaphysics. All the ground they
go upon consists in these two things, experience, and a natural sensation of a certain
fitness or agreeableness which there is in uniting such moral evil as is above described,
viz, a being or doing wrong with the will, and resentment in others, and pain inflicted
on the person in whom this moral evil is. Which natural sense is what we call by
the name of conscience.
It is true, the common people and children,
in their notion of any faulty act or deed, of any person, do suppose that it is
the person’s own act and deed. But this is all that belongs to what they understand
by a thing’s being a person’s own deed or action; even that it is something done
by him of choice. That some exercise or motion should begin of itself, does not
belong to their notion of an action or doing. If so, it would belong to their notion
of it, that it is something which is the cause of its own beginning; and that is
as much as to say, that it is before it begins to be. Nor is their notion of an
action, some motion or exercise that begins accidentally, without any cause or reason;
for that is contrary to one of the prime dictates of common sense, namely, that
every thing that begins to be, has some cause or reason why it is.
The common people, in their notion of a
faulty or praiseworthy deed or work done by any one, do suppose that the man does
it in the exercise of liberty. But then their notion of liberty is only a person’s
having opportunity of doing as he pleases. They have no notion of liberty consisting
in the will’s first acting, and so causing its own acts; and determining, and so
causing its own determinations; or choosing, and so causing its own choice. Such
a notion of liberty is what none have, but those that have darkened their own minds
with confused metaphysical speculation, and abstruse and ambiguous terms. If a man
is not restrained from acting as his will determines, or constrained to act otherwise,
then he has liberty, according to common notions of liberty, without taking into
the idea that grand contradiction of all, the determinations of a man’s free will
being the effects of the determinations of his free will.— Nor have men commonly
any notion of freedom consisting in indifference. For if so, then it would he agreeable
to their notion, that the greater indifference men act with, the more freedom they
act with; whereas the reverse is true. He that, in acting, proceeds with the fullest
inclination, does what he does with the greatest freedom, according to common sense.
And so far is it from being agreeable to common sense, that such liberty as consists
in indifference is requisite to praise or blame, that, on the contrary, the dictate
of every man’s natural sense through the world is, that the further he is from being
indifferent in His acting good or evil, and the more he does either with full and
strong inclination, the more is he esteemed or abhorred, commended or condemned.
II. If it were inconsistent with the common
sense of mankind, that men should be either to be blamed or commended in any volitions
they have or fail of, in case of moral necessity or impossibility; then it would
surely also be agreeable to the same sense and reason of mankind, that the nearer
the case approaches to such a moral necessity or impossibility, either through a
strong antecedent moral propensity, on the one hand or a great antecedent opposition
and difficulty on the other, the nearer does it approach to a being neither blameable
nor commendable; so that acts exerted with such preceding propensity, would be worthy
of proportionably less praise; and when omitted, the act being attended with such
difficulty, the omission would be worthy of less blame. It is so, as was observed
before, with natural necessity and impossibility, propensity and difficulty: as
it is a plain dictate of the sense of all mankind, that natural necessity and impossibility
take away all blame and praise; and therefore, that the nearer the approach is to
these, through previous propensity or difficulty, so praise and blame are proportionably
diminished. And if it were as much a dictate of common sense, that moral necessity
of doing or impossibility of avoiding takes away all praise and blame, as that natural
necessity or impossibility does this; then, by a perfect parity of reason, it would
be as much the dictate of common sense, that an approach to moral necessity of doing,
or impossibility of avoiding, diminishes praise and blame, as that an approach to
natural necessity and impossibility does so. It is equally the voice of common sense,
that persons are excusable in part in neglecting things difficult against their
wills, as that they are excusable wholly in neglecting things impossible against
their wills. And if it made no difference, whether the impossibility were natural
and against the will, or moral lying in the will, with regard to excusableness;
so neither would it make any difference, whether the difficulty, or approach to
necessity, be natural against the will, or moral, lying in the propensity of the
will.
But it is apparent, that the reverse of
these things is true. If there be an approach to a moral necessity in a man’s exertion
of good acts of will, they being the exercise of a strong propensity to good, and
a very powerful love to virtue; it is so far from being the dictate of common sense,
that he is less virtuous, and the less to be esteemed, loved, and praised; that
it is agreeable to the natural notions of all mankind, that he is so much the better
man, worthy of greater respect, and higher commendation. And the stronger the inclination
is, and the nearer it approaches to necessity in that respect; or to impossibility
of neglecting the virtuous act, or of doing a vicious one; still the more virtuous,
and worthy of higher commendation. And, on the other hand, if a man exerts evil
acts of mind; as for instance, acts of pride or malice, from a rooted and strong
habit or principle of haughtiness and maliciousness, and a violent propensity of
heart to such acts; according to the natural sense of men, he is so far from being
the less hateful and blameable on that account, that he is so much the more worthy
to be detested and condemned by all that observe him.
Moreover, it is manifest that it is no
part of the notion, which mankind commonly have of a blameable or praiseworthy act
of the will, that it is an act which is not determined by an antecedent bias or
motive, but by the sovereign power of the will itself; because, if so, the greater
hand such causes have in determining any acts of the will, so much the less virtuous
or vicious would they be accounted; and the less hand, the more virtuous or vicious.
Whereas the reverse is true: men do not think a good act to be the less praiseworthy
for the agent’s being much determined in it by a good inclination or a good motive,
but the more. And if good inclination or motive has but little influence in determining
the agent, they do not think his act so much the more virtuous, but the less. And
so concerning evil acts, which are determined by evil motives or inclinations.
Yea, if it be supposed, that good or evil
dispositions are implanted in the hearts of men by nature itself; (which, it is
certain, is vulgarly supposed in innumerable cases,) yet it is not commonly supposed,
that men are worthy of no praise or dispraise for such dispositions; although what
is natural is undoubtedly necessary, nature being prior to all acts of the will
whatsoever. Thus, for instance, if a man appears to be of a very haughty or malicious
disposition, and is supposed to be so by his natural temper, it is no vulgar notion,
no dictate of the common sense and apprehension of men, that such dispositions are
no vices or moral evils, or that such persons are not worthy of disesteem, or odium
and dishonour; or that the proud or malicious acts which flow from such natural
dispositions, are worthy of no resentment. Yea, such vile natural dispositions,
and the strength of them, will commonly be mentioned rather as an aggravation of
the wicked acts that come from such a fountain, than an extenuation of them. Its
being natural for men to act thus, is often observed by men in the height of their
indignation: they will say, “It is his very nature; he is of a vile natural temper;
it is as natural to him to act so, as it is to breathe; he cannot help serving the
devil,” &c. But it is not thus with regard to hurtful, mischievous things, that
any are the subjects or occasions of, by natural necessity, against their inclinations.
In such a case, the necessity, by the common voice of mankind, will be spoken of
as a full excuse.— Thus, it is very plain, that common sense makes a vast difference
between these two kinds of necessity, as to the judgment it makes of their influence
on the moral quality and desert of men’s actions.
And these dictates of men’s minds are so
natural and necessary, that it may be very much doubted whether, the Arminians themselves
have ever got rid of them; yea, their greatest doctors, that have gone furthest
in defense of their metaphysical notions of liberty, and have brought their arguments
to their greatest strength, and, as they suppose, to a demonstration, against the
consistence of virtue and vice with any necessity; it is to be questioned, whether
there is so much as one of them, but that, if he suffered very much from the injurious
acts of a man under the power of an invincible haughtiness and malignancy of temper,
would not, from the fore-mentioned natural sense of mind, resent it far otherwise,
than if as great sufferings came upon him from the wind that blows, and fire that
burns, by natural necessity; and otherwise than he would, if he suffered as much
from the conduct of a man perfectly delirious; yea, though he first brought his
distraction upon him some way by his own fault.
Some seem to disdain the distinction that
we make between natural and moral necessity, as though it were altogether impertinent
in this controversy: “that which is necessary (say they) is necessary; it is that
which must be, and cannot be prevented. And that which is impossible, is impossible,
and cannot be done: and therefore none can be to blame for not doing it,” And such
comparisons are made use of, as the commanding of a man to walk who has lost his
legs, and condemning and punishing him for not obeying; inviting and calling upon
a man who is shut up in a strong prison, to come forth, &c. But, in these things,
Arminians are very unreasonable. Let common sense determine whether there be not
a great difference between these two cases; the one, that of a man who has offended
his prince, and is cast into prison; and after he has laid there a while, the king
comes to him, calls him to come forth to him; and tells him, that if he will do
so, and will fall down before him, and humbly beg his pardon, he shall be forgiven
and set at liberty, and also be greatly enriched, and advanced to honour; the prisoner
heartily repents of the folly and wickedness of his offence against his prince,
is thoroughly disposed to abase himself, and accept of the king’s offer; but is
confined by strong walls, with gates of brass, and bars of iron. The other case
is, that of a man who is of a very unreasonable spirit, of a haughty, ungrateful,
wilful disposition; and, moreover, has been brought up in traitorous principles,
and has his heart possessed with an extreme and inveterate enmity to his lawful
sovereign; and for his rebellion is cast into prison, and lies long there, loaded
with heavy chains, and in miserable circumstances. At length the compassionate prince
comes to the prison, orders his chains to be knocked off, and his prison-doors to
be set wide open; calls to him, and tells him, if he will come forth to him, and
fall down before him, acknowledge that he has treated him unworthily, and ask his
forgiveness, he shall be forgiven, set at liberty, and set in a place of great dignity
and profit in his court. But he is stout and stomachful, and full of haughty malignity,
that he cannot be willing to accept the offer: his rooted strong pride and malice
have perfect power over him, and as it were bind him, by binding his heart: the
opposition of his heart has the mastery over him, having an influence on his mind
far superior to the king’s grace and condescension, and to all his kind offers and
promises. Now, is it agreeable to common sense to assert, and stand to it, that
there is no difference between these two cases, as to any worthiness of blame in
the prisoners; because, forsooth, there is a necessity in both, and the required
act in each case is impossible? It is true, a man’s evil dispositions may be as
strong and immoveable as the bars of a castle. But who cannot see, that when a man,
in the latter case, is said to be unable to obey the command, the expression is
used improperly, and not in the sense it has originally, and in common speech; and
that it may properly be said to be in the rebel’s power to come out of prison, seeing
he can easily do it if he pleases; though by reason of his vile temper of heart,
which is fixed and rooted, it is impossible that it should please him?
Upon the whole, I presume there is no person
of good understanding, who impartially considers the things which have been observed,
but will allow, that it is not evident, from the dictates of the common sense, or
natural notions of mankind, that moral necessity is inconsistent with praise and
blame. And, therefore, if the Arminians would prove any such inconsistency, it must
be by some philosophical and metaphysical arguments, and not common sense.
There is a grand illusion in the pretended
demonstration of Arminians from common sense. The main strength of all these demonstrations
lies in that prejudice, that arises through the insensible change of the use and
meaning of such terms as liberty, able, unable, necessary, impossible, unavoidable,
invincible, action, &c. from their original and vulgar sense, to a metaphysical
sense, entirely diverse; and the strong connection of the ideas of blamelessness,
&c. with some of these terms, by a habit contracted and established while these
terms were used in their first meaning. This prejudice and delusion is the foundation
of all those positions they lay down as maxims, by which most of the Scriptures,
which they allege in this controversy, are interpreted, and on which all their pompous
demonstrations from Scripture and reason depend. From this secret delusion and prejudice
they have almost all their advantages; it is the strength of their bulwarks, and
the edge of their weapons. And this is the main ground of all the right they have
to treat their neighbours in so assuming a manner, and to insult others, perhaps
as wise and good as themselves, as weak bigots, men that dwell in the dark caves
of superstition, perversely set, obstinately shutting their eyes against the noon-day
light, enemies to common sense, maintaining the first-born of absurdities, &c. &c.
But perhaps an impartial consideration of the things which have been observed in
the preceding parts of this Inquiry, may enable the lovers of truth better to judge,
whose doctrine is indeed absurd, abstruse, self-contradictory, and inconsistent
with common sense, and many ways repugnant to the universal dictates of the reason
of mankind.
Corol. From things which have been observed,
it will follow, that it is agreeable to common sense to suppose that the glorified
saints have not their freedom at all diminished in any respect: and that God himself
has the highest possible freedom according to the true and proper meaning of the
term; and that he is, in the highest possible respect, an agent and active in the
exercise of his infinite holiness; though he acts therein, in the highest degree
necessarily: and his actions of this kind, are in the highest, most absolutely perfect
manner, virtuous and praiseworthy; and are so, for that very reason, because they
are most perfectly necessary.