Book I.
Who Faustus was. Faustus’s object in writing the polemical treatise that forms the basis
of Augustin’s reply. Augustin’s remarks thereon.
1. Faustus was an African by race, a citizen of Mileum; he was eloquent and clever, but
had adopted the shocking tenets of the Manichæan heresy. He is mentioned in my Confes-
sions,296 where there is an account of my acquaintance with him. This man published a
certain volume against the true Christian faith and the Catholic truth. A copy reached us,
and was read by the brethren, who called for an answer from me, as part of the service of
love which I owe to them. Now, therefore, in the name and with the help of our Lord and
Saviour Jesus Christ, I undertake the task, that all my readers may know that acuteness of
mind and elegance of style are of no use to a man unless the Lord directs his steps.297 In
the mysterious equity of divine mercy, God often bestows His help on the slow and the
156
feeble; while from the want of this help, the most acute and eloquent run into error only
with greater rapidity and willfulness. I will give the opinions of Faustus as if stated by
himself, and mine as if in reply to him.
2. Faustussaid: As the learned Adimantus, the only teacher since the sainted Manichæus
deserving of our attention, has plentifully exposed and thoroughly refuted the errors of
Judaism and of semi-Christianity, I think it not amiss that you should be supplied in writing
with brief and pointed replies to the captious objections of our adversaries, that when, like
children of the wily serpent, they try to bewilder you with their quibbles, you may be prepared
to give intelligent answers. In this way they will be kept to the subject, instead of wandering
from one thing to another. And I have placed our opinions and those of our opponent over
against one another, as plainly and briefly as possible, so as not to perplex the reader with
a long and intricate discourse.
3. Augustin replies: You warn against semi-Christians, which you say we are; but we
warn against pseudo-Christians, which we have shown you to be. Semi-Christianity may
be imperfect without being false. So, then, if the faith of those whom you try to mislead is
imperfect, would it not be better to supply what is lacking than to rob them of what they
have? It was to imperfect Christians that the apostle wrote, "joying and beholding your
conversation," and "the deficiency in your faith in Christ."298 The apostle had in view a
spiritual structure, as he says elsewhere, "Ye are God’s building;"299 and in this structure he
found both a reason for joy and a reason for exertion. He rejoiced to see part already finished;
and the necessity of bringing the edifice to perfection called for exertion. Imperfect Chris-
296 Confessions, v. 3, 6.
297 Ps. xxxvii. 23.
298 Col. ii. 5; cf. 1 Thess. iii. 10.
299 1 Cor. iii. 9.
Who Faustus was. Faustus’s object in writing the polemical treatise that forms the basis of Augustin’s reply. Augustin’s remarks thereon.
263
Who Faustus was. Faustus’s object in writing the polemical treatise that…