It would have been well had Lucifer been there in
person and not by deputy only. As it was he had gone to Antioch in
fiery haste, with a promise extorted by Eusebius to do nothing rashly.
Fanatical in his orthodoxy, quite unable to grasp the theological
differences between the various parties (his remonstrances with Hilary
upon the conciliatory efforts of the latter shew his total lack of
theology: see also Krüger, pp. 36, sq.), and concentrating
all his indignation upon persons rather than principles, Lucifer found
Antioch without a bishop; for Euzoius was an Arian, and Meletius, whose
return to the church of the Palæa was (so it seems) daily
expected, was to Lucifer little better. What to such a man could seem a
quicker way to the extinction of the schism than the immediate
ordination of a bishop whom all would respect, and whose record was one
of the most uncompromising resistance to heresy? Lucifer accordingly,
with the aid we may suppose of Kymatius and Anatolius, ordained
Paulinus, the widely-esteemed head of the irreconcileable or (to adopt
Newman’s word) protestant minority, who had never owned any
Bishop of Antioch save the deposed and banished Eustathius. The act of
Lucifer had momentous consequences (see D.C.B. on Meletius and Flavian, &c.);
it perpetuated the existing tendency to schism between East and West;
and but for the forbearance of Athanasius it would perhaps have wrecked
the alliance of Conservative Asia with Nicene orthodoxy which his later
years cemented. Even as it was, the relations between Athanasius and
Basil were sorely tried by the schism of Antioch. The Tome however was
signed by Paulinus This is
placed later in 363 by Dr. Bright, D.C.B. i. 199, on the ground of a
statement of Epiphanius, Hær. 77. 20, which, however, is
not quite decisive on the point., who added a short
statement of his own faith, which, by recognising the legitimacy of the
theological language of the other catholic party at Antioch, implicitly
conceded the falseness of his own position.