4, 5. Our Lord introduces this incident as shewing that whether the band of man or (so called) accidents, lead to inflictions of this kind, it is in fact but one Hand which doeth it all—Amos 3:6. There is also a transference from the Galilæans—a despised people—to the inhabitants of Jerusalem, on whom the fulness of God’s wrath was to be poured out in case of impenitence. Of the incident itself, or of the tower in Siloam (probably the district in which the fountain, John 9:7, was situated,—though on the whole matter, and the situation of the fountain itself, there is considerable uncertainty), we know nothing. Josephus says of the wall of the ancient city, πρὸςνότονὑπὲρτὴνΣιλωὰμἐπιστρέφονπηγήν, B. J. ver. 4. 2: see also Nehemiah 3:15.
In B. J. vi. 7. 2, he uses μέχριτοῦΣιλωάμ, as here, meaning apparently a district of the city: see on John l. c.
ὀφειλέται, sinners,—see Matthew 6:12;—perhaps the same thought may be traced as pervading the saying, as in Luke 12:58-59, of the last chapter. (No such idea as that the tower was a prison for debtors is for a moment to be thought of.)
ὡσαύτως ] See on ὁμοίως above,—similarly—in the ruin of your whole city. This does not render it necessary that these words should have been spoken to actual dwellers in Jerusalem: for nearly the whole nation was assembled there at the time of the siege.