or that mode of utterance. Accordingly, if God is ungenerate before the creation of man,
we must esteem as of no account the words which indicate that thought, inasmuch as they
are dispersed along with the sounds that express them, if such thought happen to be named
after human notion. For to be, and to be called, are not convertible terms. But God is by His
nature what He is, but He is called by us by such names as the poverty of our nature will
allow us to make use of, which is incapable of enunciating thought except by means of voice
and words. Accordingly, understanding Him to be without origin, we enunciate that thought
by the term ungenerate. And what harm is it to Him Who indeed is, that He should be
named by us as we conceive Him to be? For His ungenerate existence is not the result of
His being called ungenerate, but the name is the result of the existence. But this our acute
friend fails to see, nor does he take a clear view of his own positions. For if he did, he would
certainly have left off reviling those who framed the word ungeneracy to express the idea
in their minds. For look at what he says, “Words so spoken perish as soon as they are spoken;
but God both is and was ungenerate, both after the words were spoken and before. You see
that the Supreme Being is what He is, before the creation of all things, whether silent or not,
being what He is neither in greater nor in less degree; while the use of words and names was
not devised till after the creation of man, endowed by God with the faculty of reason and
speech.”
If, then, the creation is of later date than its Creator, and man is the latest in the scale
of creation, and if speech is a distinctive characteristic of man, and verbs and nouns are the
component elements of speech, and ungeneracy is a noun, how is it that he does not under-
stand that he is combating his own arguments? For we, on our side, say that by human
thought and intelligence words have been devised expressive of things which they represent,
and he, on his side, allows that those who employ speech are demonstrably later in point of
time than the Divine life, and that the Divine nature is now, and ever has been, without
generation. If, then, he allows the blessed life to be anterior to man (for to that point I return),
and we do not deny man’s later creation, but contend that we have used forms of speech
ever since we came into being and received the faculty of reason from our Maker, and if
ungeneracy is a word expressive of a special idea, and every word is a part of human
speech,—it follows that he who admits that the Divine nature was anterior to man must at
the same time admit that the name invented by man to express that nature was itself later
in being. For it was not likely that the use of speech should be exercised before the existence
of creatures to use it, any more than that farming should be exercised before the existence
of farmers, or navigation before that of navigators, or in fact any of the occupations of life
before that of life itself. Why, then, does he contend with us, instead of following his premises
to their legitimate conclusion?
He says that God was what He is, before the creation of man. Nor do we deny it. For
whatsoever we conceive of God existed before the creation of the world. But we maintain
504
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.