It is said that these Sardican decisions were simply
provisional, and intended for the present necessity; because
Athanasius, so hardly pressed by the Arians, could only be rescued by
authorizing an appeal to the Bishop of Rome for a final judgment.
Richer, in his History of the General Councils, has elaborately
defended this opinion, and Horix also has declared in its favour.
But would not all secure use of the canons of the councils be done away
with if this distinction between provisional and permanent synodal
decisions were admitted? Is there any sure criterion for
distinguishing those canons which were only to be provisional, from the
others which were made for all future centuries? The Fathers of
the Synod of Sardica express themselves quite generally; is it not
therefore most arbitrary on our part to insert limitations? It is
beyond question that these decisions were occasioned by the very
critical state of the affairs of Athanasius; but is everything only
provisional that is occasioned by the circumstances of
individuals? In this way the most important of the ancient canons
might be set aside.