being is perfect,2400 and who is the Creator able to make out of nothing not only something,
but something great; and that the first sin, i.e. the first voluntary loss, is rejoicing in its own
power: for it rejoices in something less than would be the source of its joy if it rejoiced in
the power of God, which is unquestionably greater. Not perceiving this, and looking only
to the capacities of the human mind, and the great beauty of its achievements in word and
deed, some, who would have been ashamed to place man’s supreme good in the body, have,
by placing it in the mind, assigned to it unquestionably a lower sphere than that assigned
to it by unsophisticated reason. Among Greek philosophers who hold these views, the chief
place both in number of adherents and in subtlety of disputation has been held by the Stoics,
who have, however, in consequence of their opinion that in nature everything is material,
succeeded in turning the mind rather from carnal than material objects.
16. Among those, again, who say that our supreme and only good is to enjoy God, by
whom both we ourselves and all things were made, the most eminent have been the Platonists,
who not unreasonably judged it to belong to their duty to confute the Stoics and Epicur-
eans—the latter especially, and almost exclusively. The Academic School is identical with
the Platonists, as is shown plainly enough by the links of unbroken succession connecting
the schools. For if you ask who was the predecessor of Arcesilas, the first who, announcing
no doctrine of his own, set himself to the one work of refuting the Stoics and Epicureans,
you will find that it was Polemo; ask who preceded Polemo, it was Xenocrates; but Xenocrates
was Plato’s disciple, and by him appointed his successor in the academy. Wherefore, as to
this question concerning the supreme good, if we set aside the representatives of conflicting
views, and consider the abstract question, you find at once that two errors confront each
other as diametrically opposed—the one declaring the body, and the other declaring the
mind to be the seat of the supreme good of men. You find also that truly enlightened reason,
by which God is perceived to be our supreme good, is opposed to both of these errors, but
does not impart the knowledge of what is true until it has first made men unlearn what is
false. If now you consider the question in connection with the advocates of different views,
you will find the Epicureans and Stoics most keenly contending with each other, and the
Platonists, on the other hand, endeavouring to decide the controversy between them, con-
cealing the truth which they held, and devoting themselves only to prove and overthrow
the vain confidence with which the others adhered to error.
17. It was not in the power of the Platonists, however, to be so efficient in supporting
the side of reason enlightened by truth, as the others were in supporting their own errors.
For from them all there was then withheld that example of divine humility, which, in the
fullness of time,2401 was furnished by our Lord Jesus Christ,—that one example before
2400 Qui summe est.
2401 Opportunissimo tempore.
963
To Dioscorus