During the last decade of his life the attention
of Athanasius was drawn to the questions raised by the Arian
controversy as to the human nature of our Lord. The Arian doctrine on
this subject was apparently as old as Lucian, but the whole subject
received little or no attention in the earlier stages of the
controversy, and it was only with the rise of the Anomœan school
that the questions came into formal discussion. In the later letters of
Athanasius we see the traces of wide-spread controversy on the matter
(especially in that to Epictetus, No. 59), and Apollinarius, bishop of
the Syrian Laodicea, and a former close friend of Athanasius, whose
legates in 362 had joined in condemning the Arian Christology, broached
a peculiar theory on the subject, viz., that while Christ took a human
soul along with His Body, the Word took the place of the human
spirit, πνεῦμα (1 Thess. v. 23). The details of the system do not
belong to our subject (an excellent sketch in Gwatkin’s Arian
Controversy, pp. 136–141); in fact it was two years after the
death of Athanasius when Apollinarius definitely founded a sect by
consecrating a schismatic bishop for the already distracted Church of
Antioch. But Athanasius marked with alarm the tendency of his friend,
and in the very last years of his life wrote a tract against his tenet
in two short books, in which, as in writing against Marcellus and
Photinus 15 years before, he refrains from mentioning Apollinarius by
name. It may be observed that at the close of the second book he brings
himself for the first time to censure by name ‘him they call
Photinus,’ classing him along with Paul of Samosata.