This is the famous fourth edict of Diocletian, which was issued in
the year 304. It marks a stupendous change of method; in fact,
Christianity as such is made, for the first time since the toleration
edict of Gallienus, a religio illicita, whose profession is
punishable by death. The general persecution, in the full sense, begins
with the publication of this edict. Hitherto persecution had been
directed only against supposed political offenders and church officers.
The edict is a complete stultification of Diocletian’s principles
as revealed in the first three edicts, and shows a lamentable lack of
the wisdom which had dictated those measures. Mason has performed an
immense service in proving (to my opinion conclusively) that this
brutal edict, senseless in its very severity, was not issued by
Diocletian, but by Maximian, while Diocletian was quite incapacitated
by illness for the performance of any public duties. Mason’s
arguments cannot be reproduced here; they are given at length on p. 212
sq. of his work. He remarks at the close of the discussion:
“Diocletian, though he might have wished Christianity safely
abolished, feared the growing power of the Church, and dared not
persecute (till he was forced), lest he should rouse her from her
passivity. But this Fourth Edict was nothing more nor less than a loud
alarum to muster the army of the Church: as the centurions called over
their lists, it taught her the statistics of her numbers, down to the
last child: it proved to her that her troops could endure all the
hardships of the campaign: it ranged her generals in the exact order of
merit. Diocletian, by an exquisite refinement of thought, while he did
not neglect the salutary fear which strong penalties might inspire in
the Christians, knew well enough that though he might torture every
believer in the world into sacrificing, yet Christianity was not
killed: he knew that men were Christians again afterwards as well as
before: could he have seen deeper yet, he would have known that the
utter humiliation of a fall before men and angels converted many a hard
and worldly prelate into a broken-hearted saint: and so he rested his
hopes, not merely on the punishment of individuals, but on his three
great measures for crushing the corporate life,—the destruction
of the churches, the Scriptures, and the clergy. But this Fourth Edict
evidently returns with crass dullness and brutal complacency to the
thought that if half the church were racked till they poured the
libations, and the other half burned or butchered, Paganism would reign
alone forever more, and that the means were as eminently desirable as
the end. Lastly, Diocletian had anxiously avoided all that could rouse
fanatic zeal. The first result of the Fourth Edict was to rouse
it.”
According to the
Passio S. Sabini, which Mason accepts as in the main reliable,
and which forms the strongest support for his theory, the edict was
published in April, 304. Diocletian, meanwhile, as we know from
Lactantius (de Mort. pers. 17) did not recover sufficiently to
take any part in the government until early in the year 305, so that
Maximian and Galerius had matters all their own way during the entire
year, and could persecute as severely as they chose. As a result, the
Christians, both east and west, suffered greatly during this
period.