thinking beginning and end the same, did you, combining under one signification these
two words which denote privation of each other,—end, I mean, and beginning,—and taking
the being without end as convertible with the being without end, blend and confound one
word with the other; and is this the meaning of such a mixing up of words, when you say
that He is ungenerate as being without end, and that He is without end as being ungenerate?
Yet how is it that you did not see the profanity as well as the ridiculous folly of your words?
For if by this novel confusion of the words they are made convertible, so that ungenerate
means ungenerate without end, and that which is without end is such ungenerately, it follows
by necessity that that which is without end must needs be so as being ungenerate: and thus
it comes to pass, my good friend, that your much-talked-of ungeneracy, which you say is
the only characteristic of the Father’s essence, will be found to be shared with whatever is
immortal, and to be making all things consubstantial with the Father, because it is alike
apparent in all things whose life, by reason of their immortality, goes on to infinity,
archangels, that is, angels, human souls, and, it may be also, in the Apostate host, the Devil
and his dæmons. For if that which is without end, and imperishable, must also by your ar-
gument be ungenerately imperishable, then in whatsoever is without end and imperishable
there must be connoted ungeneracy. These are the absurdities into which those men fall
who, before they have learnt what it is fitting for them to learn, only publish their own ig-
norance by what they attempt to teach. For if he had any faculty of discernment, he would
not be ignorant of the peculiar sense inherent in his terms, “without beginning,” and “without
end,” and that the term without end is common to all things whose life we believe capable
of extension to infinity, while the term without beginning belongs to Him alone Who is
without originating cause. How, then, is it possible for us to regard that which is common
to them all, as equivalent to that which is believed by all to be a special attribute of the Deity
alone, so that we thereby either extend ungeneracy to everything that shares in immortality,
or else must not allow immortality to any one of them, seeing that the being without end is
to belong only to the ungenerate, and vice versa, the being ungenerate is to belong only to
that which is without end? Thus everything without end would have to be regarded as un-
generate.
But let us leave this, and along with it the usual foul deluge of calumny in his words;
and let us go on to his subsequent quotations (of Basil). But I think it would perhaps be well
to pass without examination over most of these subsequent words. For in all of them he
shows himself the same, not grappling with that which we have really said, but only inventing
for himself points for refutation which he pretends are taken from our statement. To go
305
carefully through these would be pronounced useless by any one possessed of judgment;
for any understanding reader of his book can from his very words perceive his scurrility.
He says that God’s Glory is prior to our leader’s “conception.” We too do not deny that. For
God’s glory, whatever we are to think of it, is prior not only to this present generation of
570
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.