CHAP. I.
CONCERNING THE OBJECTION, THAT TO SUPPOSE MEN BORN IN SIN,
WITHOUT THEIR CHOICE, OR ANY PREVIOUS ACT OF THEIR OWN, IS TO SUPPOSE
WHAT IS INCONSISTENT WITH THE NATURE OF SIN.
Some of the objections made against the doctrine of original sin, which have reference
to particular arguments used in defence of it, have been already considered in the handling
of those arguments. What I shall therefore now consider, are such objections as I have not
yet had occasion to notice.
There is no argument Dr. T. insists more upon, than that which is taken from the
Arminian and Pelagian notion of freedom of will, consisting in the will’s self-determination,
as necessary to the being of moral good or evil. He often urges, that if we come into the
world infected with sinful and depraved dispositions, then sin must be natural to us; and if
natural, then necessary; and if necessary, then no sin, nor any thing we are blamable for, or
that can in any respect be our fault, being what we cannot help: and he urges, that sin must
proceed from our own choice, &c. 128
Here I would observe in general, that the forementioned notion of freedom of will, as
essential to moral agency, and necessary to the very existence of virtue and sin, seems to be
a grand favourite point with Pelagians and Arminians, and all divines of such characters, in
their controversies with the orthodox. There is no one thing more fundamental in their
schemes of religion: on the determination of this one leading point depends the issue of al-
most all controversies we have with such divines. Nevertheless, it seems a needless task for
me particularly to consider that matter in this place; having already largely discussed it, with
all the main grounds of this notion, and the arguments used to defend it, in a late book on
this subject, to which I ask leave to refer the reader. It is very necessary, that the modern
prevailing doctrine concerning this point, should be well understood, and therefore thor-
oughly considered and examined: for without it there is no hope of putting an end to the
controversy about original sin, and innumerable other controversies that subsist, about
many of the main points of religion. I stand ready to confess to the forementioned modern
divines, if they can maintain their pecular notion of freedom, consisting in the self-determ-
ining power of the will, as necessary to moral agency, and can thoroughly establish it in op-
position to the arguments lying against it, then they have an impregnable castle, to which
they may repair, and remain invincible, in all the controversies they have with the reformed
divines, concerning original sin, the sovereignty of grace, election, redemption, conversion,
the efficacious operation of the Holy Spirit, the nature of saving faith, perseverance of the
saints, and other principles of the like kind. However, at the same time, I think this will be
as strong a fortress for the Deists, in common with them; as the great doctrines, subverted
128 Page 125, 128-130, 186-188, 190, 200, 245, 246, 253, 258, 63, 64, 161. S. and other places.
PART IV. Containing Answers to Objections.
1134
PART IV. Containing Answers to Objections.