(c) On the sufficiency of Scripture for
the establishment of all necessary doctrine Athanasius insists
repeatedly and emphatically (c. Gent. 1, de Incarn. 5,
de Decr. 32, Vit. Ant. 16, &c., &c.); and he
follows up precept by example. ‘His works are a continuous appeal
to Scripture.’ There is no passage in his writings which
recognises tradition as supplementing Scripture, i.e., as
sanctioning articles of faith not contained in Scripture. Tradition is
recognised as authoritative in two ways: (1) Negatively, in the sense
that doctrines which are novel are prima facie condemned by the
very fact (de Decr. 7, note 2, ib. 18, Orat. i. 8,
10, ii. 34, 40, de Syn. 3, 6, 7, and Letter 59, §3);
and (2) positively, as furnishing a guide to the sense of Scripture
(see references in note on Orat. iii. 58, end of ch. xxix.). In
other words, tradition with Athanasius is a formal, not a material,
source of doctrine. His language exemplifies the necessity of
distinguishing, in the case of strong patristic utterances on the
authority of tradition, between different senses of the word. Often it
means simply truth conveyed in Scripture, and in that sense
‘handed down’ from the first, as for example c.
Apol. i. 22, ‘the Gospel tradition,’ and Letter
60. 6 (cf. Cypr. Ep. 74. 10, where Scripture is
‘divinæ traditionis caput et origo.’). Moreover,
tradition as distinct from Scripture is with Athanasius not a secret
unwritten body of teaching handed down orally The idea
of a mysterious unwritten tradition is a legacy of Gnosticism to the
Church. Irenæus, in order to meet the Gnostic appeal to a supposed
unwritten Apostolic tradition, confronts it with the consistency of the
public and normal teaching of the Churches everywhere, of which the
Roman Church is a convenient microcosm or compendium. The idea of
a παράδοσις
ἄγραφος is
adopted by Clement and Origen, and passes from the latter to Eusebius,
and to the Cappadocian Fathers (Basil de Sp. S. 27, applies it
only to practical details), Epiphanius, and later writers.
Details in Harnack ii. 90, note, cf. Salmon, Infallibility,
Lect. ix. On the somewhat different subject of the ‘Disciplina
Arcani,’ see Herzog-Plitt. s.v.
‘Arkan-Disciplia’, but is
to be found in the documents of antiquity and the writings of
the Fathers, such as those to whom he appeals in de Decr.,
&c. That ‘the appeal of Athanasius was to Scripture, that of
the Arians to tradition’ (Gwatkin) is an overstatement, in part
supported by the pre-Nicene history of the word ὁμοούσιον
(supra, p. xxxi. sq.). The rejection of this word by the
Antiochene Council (in 268–9) is met by Athanasius, de
Synod. 43, sqq., partly by an appeal to still older
witnesses in its favour, partly by the observation (§45) that
‘writing in simplicity [the Fathers] arrived not at accuracy
concerning the ὁμοούσιον,
but spoke of the word as they understood it,’ an argument
strangely like that of the Homœans (Creed of Niké, ib.
§30) that the Fathers [of Nicæa] adopted the
word ‘in simplicity.’