5. What the true effect of baptism is, and what is the
real grace conveyed by water hallowed in Christ, I will presently tell
you; meantime I will deal with this argument as it deserves. ‘An
ill knot,’ says the common proverb, ‘requires but an ill
wedge to split it.’ The text quoted by the objector, “a
bishop must be the husband of one wife,” admits of quite another
explanation. The apostle came of the Jews and the primitive Christian
church was gathered out of the remnants of Israel. Paul knew that the
Law allowed men to have children by several wives, Ex. xxi. 10. and was aware that the example of the
patriarchs had made polygamy familiar to the people. Even the very
priests might at their own discretion enjoy the same license. Lev. xxi. 7, 13. He gave commandment therefore that the
priests of the church should not claim this liberty, that they should
not take two wives or three together, but that they should each have
but one wife at one time. Perhaps you may say that this explanation
which I have given is disputed; in that case listen to another. You
must not have a monopoly of bending the Law to suit your will instead
of bending your will to suit the Law. Some by a strained interpretation
say that wives are in this passage to be taken for churches and
husbands for their bishops. A decree was made by the fathers assembled
at the council of Nicæa Canon xv. that no bishop
should be translated from one church to another, lest scorning the
society of a poor yet virgin see he should seek the embraces of a
wealthy and adulterous one. For as the word λογισμόι, that is,
“disputings,” refers to the fault and misdoing of sons in
the faith, Cf. Ph. ii. 14, 15. and as the precept concerning the
management of a house refers to the right direction of body and of
soul, 1 Tim. iii. 4. so by the wives of the bishops we are to
understand their churches. Concerning whom it is written in Isaiah,
“Make haste ye women and come from the show, for it is a people
of no understanding.” Isa. xxvii. 11, LXX. A.V. follows the Hebrew. And again
“Rise up, ye women that are wealthy, A.V. that are at
ease.
and hear my voice.” Isa. xxxii. 9. And in the Book of
Proverbs, “Who can find a virtuous woman? for her price is far
above rubies. The heart of her husband doth safely trust in
her.” Prov. xxxi. 10, 11. In the same book too it is written,
“Every wise woman buildeth her house: but the foolish plucketh it
down with her hands.” Prov. xiv. 1. Nor does this,
say they, derogate from the dignity of the episcopate; for the same
figure is used in relation to God. Jeremiah writes: “As a wife
treacherously departeth from her husband, so have ye dealt
treacherously with me, O house of Israel.” Jer. iii. 20. And the apostle employs the same
comparison: “I have espoused you,” he says to his converts,
“to one husband, that I may present you as a chaste virgin to
Christ.” 2 Cor. xi. 2. The word woman is
in the Greek ambiguous and should in all these places be understood as
meaning wife. You will say that this interpretation is harsh and does
violence to the sense. In that case give back to the scripture its
simple meaning and save me from the
necessity of fighting you on your own ground. i.e. that of
strained interpretations. I
will ask you the following question, Can a man who before his baptism
has kept a concubine, and after her death has received baptism and has
taken a wife, become a clergyman or not? You will answer me that he
can, because his first partner was a concubine and not a wife. What the
apostle condemns then, it would seem, is not mere sexual intercourse
but marriage contracts and conjugal rights. Many persons, we see,
because of narrow circumstances refuse to take upon them the burthen of
matrimony. Instead of taking wives they live with their maid-servants
and bring up as their own the children which these bear to them. Thus,
if through the bounty of the Emperor they gain for their mistresses the
right of wearing a matron’s robes, V. Dict. Ant. s. v.
stola and cf. Cic. Phil. ii. 18, 44.
they will at once come beneath the yoke of the apostle and sorely
against their will will have to receive their partners as their wedded
wives. But, if their poverty prevents them from obtaining an imperial
rescript such as I have mentioned, the decrees of the Church will vary
with the laws of Rome. Be careful therefore not to interpret the words
“the husband of one wife,” that is, of one woman, as
approving indiscriminate intercourse and condemning only contracts of
marriage.