17. The shortness of a letter compels me to hasten on. I
pass, accordingly, to the points which remain. “I say,”
remarks the apostle, “to the unmarried and widows, It is good for
them if they abide even as I. But if they cannot contain, let them
marry; for it is better to marry than to burn.” 1 Cor. vii. 8, 9. This section I have interpreted thus: Ag. Jov. i. 9. “When he has granted to those who
are married the use of wedlock, and has made clear his own wishes and
concessions, he passes on to those who are unmarried or widows, and
sets before them his own example. He calls them happy if they abide
even as he, 1 Cor. vii. 8. but he goes on, ‘if they
cannot contain, let them marry.’ He thus repeats his former
language, ‘but only to avoid fornication,’ and ‘that
Satan tempt you not for your incontinence.’ And when he says,
‘If they cannot contain, let them marry,’ he gives as a
reason for his words that ‘it is better to marry than to
burn.’ It is only good to marry, because it is bad to burn. But
take away the fire of lust, and he will not say ‘it is better to
marry.’ For a thing is said to be better in antithesis to
something which is worse, and not simply in contrast with what is
admittedly good. It is as though he said, ‘It is better to have
one eye than none.’” Shortly afterwards, apostrophizing the
apostle, I spoke thus: Ag. Jov. i. 9. “If
marriage is good in itself, do not compare it with a conflagration, but
simply say, ‘It is good to marry.’ I must suspect the
goodness of a thing which only becomes a lesser evil in the presence of
a greater one. I, for my part, would have it not a lighter evil but a
downright good.” The apostle wishes unmarried women and widows to
abstain from sexual intercourse, incites them to follow his own
example, and calls them happy if they abide even as he. But if they
cannot contain, and are tempted to quench the fire of lust by
fornication rather than by continence, it is better, he tells them, to
marry than to burn. Upon which precept I have made this comment:
“It is good to marry, simply because it is bad to burn,”
not putting forward a view of my own, but only explaining the
apostle’s precept, “It is better to marry than to
burn;” that is, it is better to take a husband than to commit
fornication. If, then, you teach that burning or fornication is good,
the good will still be surpassed by what is still better. Fornication must
still be subordinated to marriage. But if marriage is only a degree better
than the evil to which it is preferred, it cannot be of that
unblemished perfection and blessedness which suggest a comparison with
the life of angels. Suppose I say, “It is better to be a virgin
than a married woman;” in this case I have preferred to what is
good what is still better. But suppose I go a step further and say,
“It is better to marry than to commit fornication;” in that
case I have preferred, not a better thing to a good thing, but a good
thing to a bad one. There is a wide difference between the two cases;
for, while virginity is related to marriage as better is to good,
marriage is related to fornication as good is to bad. How, I should
like to know, have I sinned in this explanation? My fixed purpose was
not to bend the Scriptures to my own wishes, but simply to say what I took to be their meaning. A
commentator has no business to dilate on his own views; his duty is to
make plain the meaning of the author whom he professes to interpret.
For, if he contradicts the writer whom he is trying to expound, he will
prove to be his opponent rather than his interpreter. When I am freely
expressing my own opinion, and not commenting upon the Scriptures, then
any one that pleases may charge me with having spoken hardly of
marriage. But if he can find no ground for such a charge, he should
attribute such passages in my commentaries as appear severe or harsh to
the author commented on, and not to me, who am only his
interpreter.