According to Jerome (de vir. ill. 76) Pierius was a
presbyter and a teacher in Alexandria under the emperors Carus and
Diocletian, while Theonas was bishop there (see note 51, below), on
account of the elegance of his writings was called “the younger
Origen,” was skilled, moreover, in dialectics and rhetoric, lived
an ascetic life, and passed his later years, after the persecution, in
Rome. According to Photius, Cod. 118, he was at the head of the
catechetical school of Alexandria, was the teacher of Pamphilus, and
finally suffered martyrdom. Photius may be correct in the former
statements. The last statement is at variance with Jerome’s
distinct report which in the present instance at least is to be
decidedly preferred to that of Photius. The first statement also is
subject to grave doubt, for according to Eusebius (§30, below),
Achillas, who was made presbyter at the same time as Pierius, and who
lived until after the persecution (when he became bishop), was
principal of the school. Eusebius’ statement must be accepted as
correct, and in that case it is difficult to believe the report of
Photius, both on account of Eusebius’ silence in regard to
Pierius’ connection with the school, and also because if Pierius
was principal of the school, he must apparently have given it up while
he was still in Alexandria, or must have left the city earlier than
Jerome says. It is more probable that Photius’ report is false
and rests upon a combination of the accounts of Eusebius and Jerome. If
both the first and third statements of Photius are incorrect, little
faith can be placed on the second, which may be true, or which may be
simply a combination of the known fact that Pamphilus studied in
Alexandria with the supposed fact that Pierius was the principal of the
catechetical school while he was there. It is quite as probable that
Pamphilus studied with Achillas. Jerome tells us that a number of works
(tractatuum) by Pierius were extant in his day, among them a
long homily on Hosea (cf. also Jerome’s Comment. in Osee,
prologus). In his second epistle to Pammachius (Migne, No. 49)
Jerome refers also to Pierius’ commentary on First Corinthians,
and quotes from it the words, “In saying this Paul openly
preaches celibacy.” Photius, Cod. 119, mentions a work in
twelve books, whose title he does not name, but in which he tells us
Pierius had uttered some dangerous sentiments in regard to the Spirit,
pronouncing him inferior to the Father and the Son. This work
contained, according to Photius, a book on Luke’s Gospel, and
another on the passover, and on Hosea. Pierius’ writings are no
longer extant. The passages from Jerome’s epistle to Pammachius
and from Photius, Cod. 119, are given, with notes, by Routh,
Rel. Sac. 2d ed. III. 429 sq., and an English translation in the
Ante-Nicene Fathers, VI. p. 157. Pierius was evidently a
“younger Origen” in his theology as well as in his literary
character, as we can gather from Photius’ account of him (cf.
Harnack’s Dogmengesch. I. p. 640).