We
have no reason to doubt that Eusebius, who is the first to mention
these apocryphal epistles, really found them in the public archives at
Edessa. Moses Chorenensis, the celebrated Armenian historian of the
fifth century, who studied a long time in Edessa, is an independent
witness to their existence in the Edessene archives. Eusebius has been
accused of forging this correspondence himself; but this unworthy
suspicion has been refuted by the discovery and publication of the
original Syriac (The Doct. of Addai the Apostle, with an English
Translation and Notes, by G. Phillips, London, 1876; compare also
Contemp. Rev., May, 1877, p. 1137). The epistles were forged
probably long before his day, and were supposed by him to be genuine.
His critical insight, but not his honesty, was at fault. The apocryphal
character of these letters is no longer a matter of dispute, though
Cave and Grabe defended their genuineness (so that Eusebius is in good
company), and even in the present century Rinck (Ueber die Echtheit
des Briefwechsels des Königs Abgars mit Jesu, Zeitschrift für
Hist. Theol., 1843, II. p. 326) has had the hardihood to enter the
lists in their defense; but we know of no one else who values his
critical reputation so little as to venture upon the task.