Dialogues.
The “Eranistes”
965
or “Polymorphus”
966
of the Blessed Theodoretus, Bishop of
Cyrus.
————————————
Prologue.
Some
men, distinguished neither by family nor education, and without
any of the honourable notoriety that comes of an upright life, are
ambitious of achieving fame by wicked ways. Of these was the famous
Alexander, the coppersmith,
967
a man of no sort
of distinction at all,—no nobility of birth, no eloquence of
speech, who never led a political party nor an army in the field; who
never played the man in fight, but plied from day to day his
ignominious craft, and won fame for nothing but his mad violence
against Saint Paul.
Shimei,
968
again, an obscure person of servile rank, has become very renowned for
his audacious attack on the holy David.
It is said too that the
originator of the Manichæan heresy was a mere whipping-block of a
slave, and, from love of notoriety, composed his execrable and
superstitious writings.
The same line of conduct is
pursued by many now, who after turning their backs on the honourable
glory of virtue on account of the toil to be undergone ere it be won,
purchase to themselves the notoriety that comes of shame and disgrace.
For through eagerness to pose as champions of new doctrines they pick
up and get together the impiety of many heresies, and compile this
heresy of death.
Now I will endeavour briefly to
dispute with them, with the double object of curing them, if I can, of
their unsoundness, and of giving a word of warning to the
whole.
I call my work “Eranistes,
or Polymorphus,” for, after getting together from many unhappy
sources their baleful doctrines, they produce their patchwork and
incongruous conceit. For to call our Lord Christ God only is the way of
Simon, of Cerdo, of Marcion,
969
and of others who
share this abominable opinion.
The acknowledgment of His birth
from a Virgin, but coupled with the assertion that this birth was
merely a process of transition, and that God the Word took nothing of
the Virgin’s nature, is stolen from Valentinus and Bardesanes and
the adherents of their fables.
970
To call the godhead and the
manhood of the Lord Christ one nature is the error filched from the
follies of Apollinarius.
971
Again the attribution of
capacity of suffering to the divinity of the Christ is a theft from the
blasphemy of Arius and Eunomius. Thus the main principle of their
teaching is like beggars’ gabardines—a cento of ill-matched
rags.
So I call this work Eranistes or
Polymorphus. I shall write it in the form of a dialogue with questions
and answers, pro
positions, solutions, and antitheses, and all else that a dialogue
ought to have. I shall not insert the names of the questioners and
respondents in the body of the dialogue as did the wise Greeks of old,
but I shall write them at the side at the beginning of the paragraphs.
They, indeed, put their writings in the hands of readers highly and
variously educated, and to whom literature was life. I, on the
contrary, wish the reading of what I write, and the discovery of
whatever good it may give, to be an easy task, even to the illiterate.
This I think will be facilitated if the characters of the interlocutors
are plainly shown by their names in the margin, so the disputant who
argues on behalf of the apostolical decrees is called
“Orthodoxos,” and his opponent “Eranistes.” A
man who is fed by the charity of many we commonly call
“Beggar;” a man who knows how to get money together we call
a “Chrematistes.” So we have given our disputant this name
from his character and pursuits.
I beg that all those into whose
hands my book may fall will lay aside all preconceived opinion and put
the truth to the test. For clearness’ sake I will divide my book
into three dialogues. The first will contain the contention that the
Godhead of the only-begotten Son is immutable. The second will by
God’s help show that the union of the Godhead and the manhood of
the Lord Christ is without confusion. The third will contend for the
impassibility of the divinity of our saviour. After these three
disputations we will subjoin several others as it were to complete
them, giving formal proof under each head, and making it perfectly
plain that the apostles’ doctrine is preserved by us.
965
ἔρανος
—a
meal to which every one contributes a share; a club feast, or pic-nic,
and
ἐρανιστὴς
is in classical Greek a contributor to such a feast.
But
ἐρανίζω = (α
) “contribute,”
and (
β
)
“beg for contributions.” So
ἐρανιστὴς
is by some rendered “beggar.” The idea of
Theodoretus seems rather that his worse character is a picker up of
various scraps of heresy from different quarters, and this explanation
of the name is borne out by his use of the cognate verb
ἐρανιζομαι
in reference to the selection by Audæus of some
of the doctrines of Manes in Hist. iv. 9.
966
Polymorphus = Multiform.
967
2 Tim. iv. 14
968
2 Kings xvi.
5
969
Cerdo, the gnostic teacher of the middle of the 2nd c., and placed
by Theodoretus (Hær. Fab. i. 24) in the reign of Antoninus,
a.d.
138–161, is described by the Ps.
Tertullian as denying that Christ came in the substance of the flesh,
but in appearance only. According to Marcion the greater follower of
Cerdo, Christ was not born at all, but came down from heaven to
Capernaum
a.d.
29, his body being an
appearance and his death an illusion. Simon Magus, the “father of
all heretics” of Irenæus (adv. Hær. pr. in lib. iii.)
is apparently quoted rather as the supposed originator of Gnosticism,
than from any definite knowledge of his tenets.
970
Valentinus (taught at Rome c. 140) the arch-gnostic is identified
with the doctrine of emanation. Bardesanes (Bar Daisan), who lived some
thirty years later at Edessa, was a great leader of the Syrian school
of oriental dualism. For mention of his son Harmonius vide Hist. p.
129.
971
Condemned at Constantinople in 381.