11. For God creates, and to create is also
ascribed to men; and God has being, and men are said to be, having
received from God this gift also. Yet does God create as men do? or is
His being as man’s being? Perish the thought; we understand the
terms in one sense of God, and in another of men. For God creates, in
that He calls what is not into being, needing nothing thereunto; but
men work some existing material, first praying, and so gaining the wit
to make, from that God who has framed all things by His proper Word.
And again men, being incapable of self-existence, are enclosed in
place, and consist in the Word of God; but God is self-existent,
enclosing all things, and enclosed by none; within all according to His
own goodness and power, yet without all in His proper nature Vid.
also Incarn. §17. This contrast is not commonly found in
ecclesiastical writers, who are used to say that God is present
everywhere, in substance as well as by energy or power. S. Clement,
however, expresses himself still more strongly in the same way,
‘In substance far off (for how can the originate come close to
the Unoriginate?), but most close in power, in which the universe is
embosomed.’ Strom. 2. circ. init. but the
parenthesis explains his meaning. Vid. Cyril. Thesaur. 6. p. 44.
The common doctrine of the Fathers is, that God is present everywhere
in substance. Vid. Petav. de Deo, iii. 8. and 9. It may
be remarked, that S. Clement continues ‘neither enclosing
nor enclosed.’. As then men create not as God creates, as
their being is not such as God’s being, so men’s generation
is in one way, and the Son is from the Father in another In
Almighty God is the perfection and first pattern of what is seen in
shadow in human nature, according to the imperfection of the subject
matter; and this remark applies, as to creation, so to generation.
Athanasius is led to state this more distinctly in another connection
in Orat. i. §21. fin. ‘It belongs to the Godhead
alone, that the Father is properly (κυρίως) Father, and the Son properly (κυρίως) Son; and in Them and Them only does it hold that the
Father is ever Father, and the Son ever Son.’ Accordingly he
proceeds, shortly afterwards, as in the text, to argue, ‘For
God does not make men His pattern, but rather we men, for that God
is properly and alone truly Father of His own Son, are also
called fathers of our own children, for “of Him is every
father-hood in heaven and on earth named,”’ §23. The
Semiarians at Ancyra quote the same text for the same doctrine.
Epiphan. Hær. 73. 5. As do Cyril in Joan. i. p. 24.
Thesaur. 32. p. 281. and Damascene de Fid. Orth. i. 8.
The same parallel, as existing between creation and generation is
insisted on by Isidor. Pel. Ep. iii. 355. Basil contr.
Eun. iv. p. 280 A., Cyril Thesaur. 6. p. 43. Epiph.
Hær. 69. 36. and Gregor. Naz. Orat. 20. 9. who
observes that God creates with a word, Ps. cxlviii.
5,
which evidently transcends human creations. Theodorus Abucara, with the
same object, draws out the parallel of life, ζωὴ, as Athan. that
of being, εἶναι.
Opusc. iii. p. 420–422.. For the offspring of men are portions of
their fathers, since the very nature of bodies is not uncompounded, but
in a state of flux Vid.
de Synod. §51. Orat. i. §15, 16. ῥευστὴ. vid.
Orat. i. §28. Bas. in Eun. ii. 23. ῥύσιν. Bas. in Eun.
ii. 6. Greg. Naz. Orat. 28, 22. Vid. contr. Gentes,
§§41, 42; where Athan. without reference to the Arian
controversy, draws out the contrast between the Godhead and human
nature., and composed of
parts; and men lose their substance in begetting, and again they gain
substance from the accession of food. And on this account men in their
time become fathers of many children; but God, being without parts, is
Father of the Son without partition or passion; for there is neither
effluence S.
Cyril, Dial. iv. init. p. 505 E. speaks of the θρυλλουμένη
ἀποῤ& 191·οὴ, and disclaims it, Thesaur. 6. p. 43. Athan.
disclaims it, Expos. §1. Orat. i. §21. So does
Alexander, ap. Theod. Hist. i. 3. p. 743. On the other hand,
Athanasius quotes it in a passage which he adduces from Theognostus,
infr. §25. and from Dionysius, de Sent. D. §23.
and Origen uses it, Periarchon, i. 2. It is derived from
Wisd. vii.
25. of the Immaterial, nor influx from
without, as among men; and being uncompounded in nature, He is Father
of One Only Son. This is why He is Only-begotten, and alone in the
Father’s bosom, and alone is acknowledged by the Father to be
from Him, saying, ‘This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well
pleased Matt. iii. 17..’ And He too is the Father’s
Word, from which may be understood the impassible and impartitive
nature of the Father, in that not even a human word is begotten with
passion or partition, much less the Word of God The
title ‘Word’ implies the ineffable mode of the Son’s
generation, as distinct from material parallels, vid. Gregory
Nyssen, contr. Eunom. iii. p. 107. Chrysostom in Joan.
Hom. 2. §4. Cyril Alex. Thesaur. 5. p. 37. Also it
implies that there is but One Son. vid. infr. §16.
‘As the Origin is one essence, so its Word and Wisdom is one,
essential and subsisting.’ Orat. iv. 1. fin..
Wherefore also He sits, as Word, at the Father’s right hand; for
where the Father is, there also is His Word; but we, as His works,
stand in judgment before Him; and, while He is adored, because He is
Son of the adorable Father, we adore, confessing Him Lord and God,
because we are creatures and other than He.