persons, and to treat them accordingly, and so to receive them into the christian church,
and to its special ordinances.
I answer, this objection does in effect suppose and grant the very thing mainly in dispute.
For it supposes, that a gracious character is the thing that ought to be aimed at in admitting
persons into the communion of the church; and so that it is needful to have this charity for
persons, or such a favourable notion of them, in order to our receiving them as properly
qualified members of the society, and properly qualified subjects of the special privileges to
which they are admitted. Whereas, the doctrine taught is, that sanctifying grace is not a ne-
cessary qualification, and that there is no need that the person himself, or any other, should
imagine he is a person so qualified. The assigned reason is, because it is no qualification
requisite in itself; the ordinance of the Lord’s supper is as proper for them that are not
qualified as for those that are; it being according to the design of the institution a converting
ordinance, and so an ordinance as much intended for the good of the unconverted, as of the
converted; even as it is with the preaching of the gospel. Now if the case be so, why is there
any talk about a charitable hoping they are converted, and so admitting them? What need
of any charitable hope of such a qualification, in order to admitting them to an ordinance
that is as proper for those who are without this qualification, as for those that have it? We
need not have any charitable hope of any such qualification in order to admit a person to
hear the word preached. What need have we to aim at any thing beyond the proper qualific-
ations? And what need of any charitable opinion or hope of any thing further? Some sort
of belief, that Jesus is the Messiah, is a qualification properly requisite to a coming to the
Lord’s supper; and therefore it is necessary that we should have a charitable hope, that those
have such a belief whom we admit; though it be not necessary that we should know it, it
being what none can know of another. But as to grace or christian piety, it clearly follows,
on the principles which I oppose, that no kind of visibility or appearance, whether direct or
indirect, whether to a greater or less degree, no charity or hope of it, have any thing at all
to do in the affair of admission to the Lord’s supper; for, according to them, it is properly
a converting ordinance. What has any visibility or hope of a person being already in health
to do, in admitting him into an hospital for the use of those means that are appointed for
the healing of the sick, and bringing them to health? And therefore it is needless here to
dispute about the nature of visibility; and all arguing concerning a profession of christian
doctrines, and an orderly life being a sufficient ground of public charity, and an obligation
on the church to treat them as saints, are wholly impertinent and nothing to the purpose.
For on the principles which I oppose, there is no need of any ground for treating them as
saints, in order to admitting them to the Lord’s supper, the very design of which is to make
them saints, any more than there is need of some ground of treating a sick man as being a
man in health, in order to admitting him into an hospital. Persons, by the doctrine that I
oppose, are not taught to offer themselves as candidates for church communion under any
1758
SECTION I. Church members should be visible saints.