CHAP. XXVI.] PROCESSION OF THEHOLY SPIRIT IS ETERNAL. 433
if it was written of His servant and forerunner John himself,
" He shall be filled with the Holy Spirit, even from his
mother's womb," ^ because, although generated by his father,
yet he received the Holy Spirit when formed in the womb
;
what must be understood and believed of the man Christ, of
whose flesh the very conception was not carnal, but spiritual ?
Both natures, too, as well the human as the divine, are shown
in that also that is written of Him, that He received of the
Father the promise of the Holy Spirit, and shed forth the
Holy Spirit :
^ seeing that He received as man, and shed forth
as God. And we indeed can receive that gift according to our
small measure, but assuredly we cannot shed it forth upon
others ; but, that this may be done, we invoke over them God,
by whom this is accomplished.
47. Are we therefore able to ask whether the Holy Spirit
had already proceeded from the Father when the Son was born,
or had not yet proceeded, and when He was born, proceeded
from both, wherein there is no such thing as distinct times
:
just as we have been able to ask, in a case where we do
find times, that the will proceeds from the human mind first,
in order that that may be sought which, when found, may be
called offspring ; which offspring being already brought forth
or born, that will is made perfect, resting in this end, so that
what had been its desire when seeking, is its love when enjoy-
ing; which love now proceeds from both, i.e. from the mind
that begets, and from the notion that is begotten, as if from
parent and offspring ? These things it is absolutely impossible
to ask in this case, where nothing is begun in time, so as to
be perfected in a time following. Wlierefore let him who can
understand the generation of the Son from the Father without
time, understand also the procession of the Holy Spirit from
both without time. And let him who can understand, in that
which the Son says, "As the Father hath life in Himself, so
hath He given to the Son to have life in Himself," ^ not that
the Father gave life to the Son already existing without life,
but that He so begat Him apart from time, that the life which
the Father gave to the Son by begetting Him is co-eternal
with the life of the Father who gave it ; let him, I say, under-
1 Luke i. 15. ^ ^^ts ii, 33. » John v. 26.
DE TEIN. 2 E