Chapter 9.—10. Again, when he hears, "He that is washed by one dead, his washing
profiteth him nought,"1936 he will answer, "Christ, being raised from the dead, dieth no
more; death hath no more dominion over Him:"1937 of whom it is said, "The same is He
which baptizeth with the Holy Ghost."1938 But they are baptized by the dead, who are
baptized in the temples of idols. For even they themselves do not suppose that they receive
the sanctification which they look for from their priests, but from their gods; and since these
were men, and are dead in such sort as to be now neither upon earth nor in the rest of
heaven,1939 they are truly baptized by the dead: and the same answer will hold good if there
be any other way in which these words of holy Scripture may be examined, and profitably
discussed and understood. For if in this place I understand a baptizer who is a sinner, the
same absurdity will follow, that whosoever has been baptized by an ungodly man, even
523
though his ungodliness be undiscovered, is yet washed in vain, as though baptized by one
dead. For he does not say, He that is baptized by one manifestly dead, but absolutely, "by
one dead." And if they consider any man to be dead whom they know to be a sinner, but
any one in their communion to be alive, even though he manages most adroitly to conceal
a life of wickedness, in the first place with accursed pride they claim more for themselves
than they ascribe to God, that when a sinner is unveiled to them he should be called dead,
but when he is known by God he is held to be alive. In the next place, if that sinner is to be
called dead who is known to be such by men, what answer will they make about Optatus,
whom they were afraid to condemn though they had long known his wickedness? Why are
those who were baptized by him not said to have been baptized by one dead? Did he live
because the Count was his faith?1940—an elegant and well-turned saying of some early col-
leagues of their own, which they themselves are wont to quote with pride, not understanding
that at the death of the haughty Goliath it was his own sword by which his head was cut
off.1941
1936 So the Donatists commonly quoted Ecclus. xxiv. 25, which is more correctly rendered in our version,
"He that washeth himself after touching of a dead body, if he touch it again, what availeth his washing?" Augustin
(Retractt. i. 21, 3) says that the misapplication was rendered possible by the omission in many African Mss. of
the second clause, "and touches it again." Cp. Hieron, Ecclus. xxxiv. 30.
1937 Rom. vi. 9.
1938 John i. 33.
1939 Cp. Contra Cresconium, Book II. 25-30: "Ita mortui sunt, ut neque super terras, neque in requie sanctorum
vivant."
1940 Benedictines suggest as an emendation "quod Deus illi comes erat," as in II. 23, 53; 37, 88, 103, 237.
1941 1 Sam. xvii. 51.
Chapter 9
990
Chapter 9