10. But this would be the act of one contumacious, not of one who knew his position.
See, O Emperor, you are already yourself partially rescinding your law, would that it were
not partially but altogether! for I would not that your law should be set above the law of
God. The law of God has taught us what to follow; human laws cannot teach us this. They
usually extort a change from the fearful, but they cannot inspire faith.
11. Who, then, will there be, who when he reads that at one instant through so many
provinces the order was given, that whoever acts against the Emperor shall be beheaded,
that whoever does not give up the temple of God shall at once be put to death; who, say, is
there who will be able either alone or with a few others to say to the Emperor: I do not ap-
prove of your law? Priests are not allowed to say this, are then laymen allowed? And shall
he judge concerning the faith who either hopes for favour or is afraid of giving offence?
12. Lastly, shall I myself choose laymen for judges, who, if they upheld the truth of their
faith, would be either proscribed or put to death, as that law passed concerning the faith
decrees? Shall I then expose these men either to denial of the truth or to punishment?
13. Ambrose is not of sufficient importance to degrade the priesthood on his own ac-
count. The life of one is not of so much value as the dignity of all priests, by whose advice
I gave those directions, when they intimated that there might perchance be some heathen
or Jew chosen by Auxentius, to whom I should give a triumph over Christ, if I entrusted to
him a judgment concerning Christ. What else pleases them but to hear of some insult to
Christ? What else can please them unless (which God forbid) the Godhead of Christ should
be denied? Plainly they agree well with the Arian who says that Christ is a creature, which
also heathen and Jews most readily acknowledge.
14. This was decreed at the Synod of Ariminum, and rightly do I detest that council,
following the rule of the Nicene Council, from which neither death nor the sword can detach
me, which faith the father of your Clemency also, Theodosius, the most blessed Emperor,
both approved and follows. The Gauls hold this faith, and Spain, and keep it with the pious
confession of the Divine Spirit.
15. If anything has to be discussed I have learnt to discuss it in church as those before
me did. If a conference is to be held concerning the faith, there ought to be a gathering of
Bishops, as was done under Constantine, the Prince of august memory, who did not promul-
gate any laws beforehand, but left the decision to the Bishops. This was done also under
Constantius, Emperor of august memory, the heir of his father’s dignity. But what began
well ended otherwise, for the Bishops had at first subscribed an unadulterated confession
of faith, but since some were desirous of deciding concerning the faith inside the palace,
they managed that those decisions of the Bishops should be altered by fraud. But they im-
mediately recalled this perverted decision, and certainly the larger number at Ariminum
approved the faith of the Nicene Council and condemned the Arian propositions.
915
Letter XXI: To Valentinian II., Declining Challenge of Auxentius.