The objection to the second edict on the part of the Donatists respecting the restriction
upon the number to be present at the collation, led the Catholics to write a second letter to
Marcellinus, which is most likely also from the pen of Augustin. [Ep. cxxix.]. Solicitude
over the opposition is expressed; some seem disposed to present a hindrance to the peaceful
progress of the Conference; and yet the writers hope that the thought and suspicion may
not prove true, but that the desire of the whole body may after all be to press into the unity
of the Catholic Church. Then they go on, very wrongfully in such a document, to discuss
their favorite note of the universality of the Church, as the body of Christ was not stolen,
so neither are His members outside of the few in Africa, dead. From Jerusalem outward
was to be its progress and thence it filled the whole world. The fact that the Donatists have
the very same Scriptures as the Catholics which contain these proofs of universality, fills
the complainants with grief for them. The Jews who denied the resurrection rejected also
the New Testament; but the Donatists receive it, and yet they deny the note of universality,
and accuse the Catholics of being traditors of the sacred books. Now at the collation probably
they wish to be in full numbers, in order to search completely the Scriptures; and through
their innumerable testimonies they long to come en masse, not to create a tumult, but to
put an end to the old discord. It is true that they have found fault with our use of the State;
and yet the Scriptures vindicate such a recourse, and the Donatists themselves appealed to
Constantine. The Scriptures too show the mixed character of the Church, wheat and chaff,
394
good and bad fish, to the final harvest, the winnowing, and the further shore. Perhaps they
see the wrong of their opposition to the Church. The case of the Maximianists has shown
their willingness to use the power of the State and to ignore rebaptism; and probably moved
by these things, they want to come in such large numbers in the interest not of tumult but
of peace. They desire to show that they are not so few as their enemies report them to be.
The Catholic numbers exceed in proconsular Africa, and, except in Numidia, are more nu-
merous than in the rest of the African provinces; and most of all when one comes to compare
the whole world with the few Donatists. Why, however, could not the number be just as
well certified by the subscription? Even though quiet be preserved, yet at such a Conference
the murmur of such a crowd will impede the progress of the work. If they all are allowed
to be present, the writers, nevertheless, will limit themselves to the delegation suggested by
the Judge, and then no blame for disorder can attach to them. If, however, the protest has
been made in behalf of unity, they all will be present joyfully to welcome the Donatists as
brethren.
The Mandatum Catholicorum, a sort of voucher and letter of instruction for the dis-
putants on the side of the State Church, was undoubtedly the product of Augustin’s pen.
After a preamble which attests the sufficiency of the Church through her divine proofs
against all heretics and schismatics, and the desire of Church and State to settle the long
pending controversy in Africa, and the duty to enlighten men as to the eternal salvation,
675
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.