Chapter XXXV.—A refutation of those
who allege that the prophets uttered some predictions under the inspiration of
the highest, others from the Demiurge. Disagreements of the Valentinians among
themselves with regard to these same predictions.
1.
Then
again, in opposition to the Valentinians, and the other Gnostics, falsely
so called, who maintain that some parts of Scripture were spoken at one
time from the Pleroma (
a summitate
) through means of the seed
[derived] from that place, but at another time from the intermediate
abode through means of the audacious mother Prunica, but that many are
due to the Creator of the world, from whom also the prophets had their
mission, we say that it is altogether irrational to bring down the Father
of the universe to such straits, as that He should not be possessed of
His own proper instruments, by which the things in the Pleroma might be
perfectly proclaimed. For of whom was He afraid, so that He should not
reveal His will after His own way and independently, freely, and without
being involved with that spirit which came into being in a state of
degeneracy and ignorance? Was it that He feared that very many would be
saved, when more should have listened to the unadulterated truth? Or, on
the other hand, was He incapable of preparing for Himself those who
should announce the Saviour’s advent?
2. But if, when the Saviour came to this earth, He sent
His apostles into the world to proclaim with accuracy His advent, and to
teach the Father’s will, having nothing in common with the doctrine
of the Gentiles or of the Jews, much more, while yet existing in the
Pleroma, would He have appointed His own heralds to proclaim His future
advent into this world, and having nothing in common with those
prophecies originating from the Demiurge. But if, when within the
Pleroma, He availed Himself of those prophets who were under the law, and
declared His own matters through their instrumentality; much more would
He, upon His arrival hither, have made use of these same teachers, and
have preached the Gospel to us by their means. Therefore let them not any
longer assert that Peter and Paul and the other apostles proclaimed the
truth, but that it was the scribes and Pharisees, and the others, through
whom the law was propounded. But if, at His advent, He sent forth His own
apostles in the spirit of truth, and not in that of error, He did the
very same also in the case of the prophets; for the Word of God was
always the self-same: and if the Spirit from the Pleroma was, according
to these men’s system, the Spirit of light, the Spirit of truth,
the Spirit of perfection, and the Spirit of knowledge, while that from
the Demiurge was the spirit of ignorance, degeneracy, and error, and the
offspring of obscurity; how can it be, that in one and the same being
there exists perfection and defect, knowledge and ignorance, error and
truth, light and darkness? But if it was impossible that such should
happen in the case of the prophets, for they preached the word of the
Lord from one God, and proclaimed the advent of His Son, much more would
the Lord Himself never have uttered words, on one occasion from above,
but on another from degeneracy below, thus becoming the teacher at once
of knowledge and of ignorance; nor would He have ever glorified as Father
at one time the Founder of the world, and at another Him who is above
this one, as He does Himself declare: “No man putteth a piece of a
new garment upon an old one, nor do they put new wine into old
bottles.”
4352
Let these men,
therefore, either have nothing whatever to do with the prophets, as with
those that are ancients, and allege no longer that these men, being sent
beforehand by the Demiurge, spake certain things under that new influence
which pertains to the Pleroma; or, on the other hand, let them be
convinced by our Lord, when He declares that new wine cannot be put into
old bottles.
3. But from what source could the offspring of their
mother derive his knowledge of the mysteries within the Pleroma, and
power to discourse regarding them? Suppose that the mother, while beyond
the Pleroma, did bring forth this very offspring; but what is beyond the
Pleroma they represent as being beyond the pale of knowledge, that is,
ignorance. How, then, could that seed, which was conceived in ignorance,
possess the power of declaring knowledge? Or how did the mother herself,
a shapeless and undefined being, one cast out of doors as an abortion,
obtain knowledge of the mysteries within the Pleroma, she who was
organized outside it and given a form there, and prohibited by Horos from
entering within, and who remains outside the Pleroma till the
consummation [of all things], that is, beyond the pale of knowledge?
Then, again, when they say that the Lord’s passion is a type of the
extension of the Christ above, which he effected through Horos, and so
imparted a form to their mother, they are refuted in the other
particulars [of the Lord’s passion], for they have no semblance of
a type to show with regard
to them. For when did the Christ
above have vinegar and gall given him to drink? Or when was his raiment
parted? Or when was he pierced, and blood and water came forth? Or when
did he sweat great drops of blood? And [the same may be demanded] as to
the other particulars which happened to the Lord, of which the prophets
have spoken. From whence, then, did the mother or her offspring divine
the things which had not yet taken place, but which should occur
afterwards?
4. They affirm that certain things still, besides
these, were spoken from the Pleroma, but are confuted by those which are
referred to in the Scriptures as bearing on the advent of Christ. But
what these are [that are spoken from the Pleroma] they are not agreed,
but give different answers regarding them. For if any one, wishing to
test them, do question one by one with regard to any passage those who
are their leading men, he shall find one of them referring the passage in
question to the Propator—that is, to Bythus; another attributing
it to Arche—that is, to the Only-begotten; another to the Father
of all—that is, to the Word; while another, again, will say that
it was spoken of that one Æon who was [formed from the joint
contributions] of the Æons in the Pleroma;
4353
others [will regard the passage] as referring to Christ, while another
[will refer it] to the Saviour. One, again, more skilled than these,
4354
after a long protracted
silence, declares that it was spoken of Horos; another that it signifies
the Sophia which is within the Pleroma; another that it announces the
mother outside the Pleroma; while another will mention the God who made
the world (the Demiurge). Such are the variations existing among them
with regard to one [passage], holding discordant opinions as to the same
Scriptures; and when the same identical passage is read out, they all
begin to purse up their eyebrows, and to shake their heads, and they say
that they might indeed utter a discourse transcendently lofty, but that
all cannot comprehend the greatness of that thought which is implied in
it; and that, therefore, among the wise the chief thing is silence. For
that Sige (
silence
) which is above must be typified by that
silence which they preserve. Thus do they, as many as they are, all
depart [from each other], holding so many opinions as to one thing, and
bearing about their clever notions in secret within themselves. When,
therefore, they shall have agreed among themselves as to the things
predicted in the Scriptures, then also shall they be confuted by us. For,
though holding wrong opinions, they do in the meanwhile, however, convict
themselves, since they are not of one mind with regard to the same words.
But as we follow for our teacher the one and only true God, and possess
His words as the rule of truth, we do all speak alike with regard to the
same things, knowing but one God, the Creator of this universe, who sent
the prophets, who led forth the people from the land of Egypt, who in
these last times manifested His own Son, that He might put the
unbelievers to confusion, and search out the fruit of righteousness.
4352
Luke v. 36, 37
.
4353
Book i. p. 334, this volume.
4354
Illorum; following the Greek
form of the comparative degree.