4. But the Arians we must ask contrariwise: (for
the Sabellianisers must be confuted from the notion of a Son, and the
Arians from that of a Father:) let us say then—Is God wise and
not word-less: or on the contrary, is He wisdom-less and word-less Or. i. 19, n. 5.? if the latter, there is an absurdity at
once; if the former, we must ask, how is He wise and not word-less?
does He possess the Word and the Wisdom from without, or from Himself?
If from without, there must be one who first gave to Him, and before He
received He was wisdom-less and word-less. But if from Himself, it is
plain that the Word is not from nothing, nor once was not; for He was
ever; since He of whom He is the Image, exists ever. But if they say
that He is indeed wise and not word-less, but that He has in Himself
His own wisdom and own word, and that, not Christ, but that by which He
made Christ, we must answer that, if Christ in that word was brought to
be, plainly so were all things; and it must be He of whom John says,
‘All things were made by Him,’ and the Psalmist, ‘In
Wisdom hast Thou made them all John i. 3; Ps. civ.
24..’ And Christ
will be found to speak untruly, ‘I in the Father,’ there
being another in the Father. And ‘the Word became flesh John i. 14.’ is not true according to them. For if
He in whom ‘all things came to be,’ Himself became flesh,
but Christ is not in the Father, as Word ‘by whom all things came
to be,’ then Christ has not become flesh, but perhaps Christ was
named Word. But if so, first, there will be another besides the name,
next, all things were not by Him brought to be, but in that other, in
whom Christ also was made. But if they say that Wisdom is in the Father
as a quality or that He is Very Wisdom §2.,
the absurdities will follow already mentioned. For He will be
compound §9, fin., and will prove His own Son and
Father §10.. Moreover, we must confute and silence
them on the ground, that the Word which is in God cannot be a creature
nor out of nothing; but if once a Word be in God, then He must be
Christ who says, ‘I am in the Father and the Father in Me John xiv. 20.,’ who also is therefore the
Only-begotten, since no other was begotten from Him. This is One Son,
who is Word, Wisdom, Power; for God is not compounded of these, but is generative iii.
66, n. 3. of
them. For as He frames the creatures by the Word, so according to the
nature of His own Essence has He the Word as an Offspring, through whom
He frames and creates and dispenses all things. For by the Word and the
Wisdom all things have come to be, and all things together remain
according to His ordinance Ps. cxix. 91.. And the same
concerning the word ‘Son;’ if God be without Son Or. ii. 2, n. 3., then is He without Work; for the Son is His
Offspring through whom He works Or. ii. 41; iii. 11, n. 4.; but if not,
the same questions and the same absurdities will follow their
audacity.