For a demonstration of the same truth, miracles are
wrought to effect physical cures, mental troubles, threatened dangers,
casting out of demons, silencing philosophers and wordy ecclesiastics,
vindicating orthodoxy, reading the thoughts of hypocrites defeating
enemies, sanctifying the
sacraments’ raising the dead; and they are the mighty agents for
converting philosophers, Jews, pagans, and heretics. They are wrought
by the hands of the eminently excellent only; the gift is associated
with a high measure of grace; for example the bishops Paphnutius (i.
10) and Spyridion (i. 11) are so endowed; Alexander of Constantinople
(i. 14), Eusebius of Emesa (iii. 6), Martin of Tours (iii. 14),
Arsacius of Nicomedia (iv. 16), Donatus (vii. 26), Gregory of
Neocæsarea (vii. 26), Theotimus of Scythia (vii. 26), Epiphanius
of Salamis (vii. 27). In like manner, the monks Antony (i. 13), Amun
(i. 14), Eutychianus (i. 14), Macarius the Egyptian, Apollonius,
Hilarion, Julian (iii. 14), John, Copres, Helles, Apelles, Eulogius
(vi. 28); Apollos, John of Diolchus, Benjamin and Pior (vi. 29). The
united prayer of a congregation could effect them (vii. 5). The statue
of Christ at Paneas, the fountain at Emmaus, the tree at Hermopolis (v.
21), were all miraculous centers. The spot where the Archangel Michael
appeared (ii. 3), the places where the head of John the Baptist reposed
(vii. 21), the tombs of monks, martyrs, and bishops,—as of
Hilarion (iii. 14), Martyrius and Marcianus (iv. 3), Epiphanius (vii.
27),—were replete with restorative virtues. Sozomen had such a
miracle wrought upon himself; he believed thoroughly in an
uninterrupted stream of charismata; he deemed it necessary for the
maintenance of the faith. He was no more credulous than Socrates, or
Theodoret, or Evagrius, or Theodore. To criticise him for his belief in
this respect is to forget the Christian consciousness of the age. And
the historic school which seeks to eliminate the volume of testimony,
in the assumption that miracles do not fall within the province of
history, ignores the first law of that science, which requires the
reproduction of all facts, in time and place, whatever they may be,
that are affiliated with the evolution of the human will; that other
older school which dismisses all ecclesiastical miracles on the a
prioriassumption that these energies ceased at a time co-ordinate
with the death of the Apostles, or at a point not far removed from
their age, violates the spirit of induction. These miracles must be
tested by evidence, and the laws of supernatural energy, and in no
other way. To Sozomen and all his contemporaries the miracle appeared
essential both to the proof of the divine origin of Christianity, and
to offset and withstand the influence of the theurgic arts of the
philosophers, such as Julianus and many of the Neoplatonists. As he
remarks concerning the reply made by Alexander, bishop of
Constantinople, when he silenced the philosopher by the simple
authority of Christ, “It is then right to consider whether it is
a greater miracle, that a man, and he a philosopher, should so easily
be silenced by a word, or that a stone wall should be cleft by the
power of a word, which miracle I have heard some attribute with pride
to Julian, surnamed the Chaldean” (i. 18). The gift of prophecy
is also represented as sustained throughout this period, and with the
same logical aims in view. The monks are especially thus endowed:
Antony (i. 13, vi. 5, 6), the two Macarii, Pachomius (iii. 14),
Arsacius (iv. 16), John (vi. 28, vii. 22, vii. 28), Theon (vi. 28),
Isaac (vi. 40); so the bishops Athanasius (iv. 10), Chrysostom and
Epiphanius, rather abusively (viii. 15); so royal persons, such as the
wife of Valens, passively (vi. 16), Pulcheria, directly and passively
(ix. 3). The perpetuation of this charism was deemed inherently
necessary for the sake of historical continuity, and to prove as well
that the faith he loved had been established by God; equally was it
requisite as a holy parallel whereby to gainsay the mantic spirit of
Paganism; as is best illustrated in the silencing of the oracle at
Daphne (v. 19), and by his reflections upon the philosopher’s
tripod devised for finding the successor of Valens (vi. 35). Nor are
Socrates, Theodoret, Evagrius, and others any more moderate than
Sozomen in this respect.