It has been necessary to dwell upon the work of
this famous Council in view of its subsequent importance. It is easy to
see how the Eastern bishops were prevailed upon to take the bold step
of putting forth a Creed to rival the Nicene formula. The formal
approval of Marcellus at Rome shewed, so they felt, the inadequacy of
that formula to exclude Sabellianism, or rather the direct support
which that heresy could find in the word ‘homoüsion.’
This being so, provided they made it clear that they were not favouring
Arianism, they would be doing no more than their duty in providing a
more efficient test. But here the Arian group saw their opportunity.
Conservative willingness to go behind Nicæa must be made to
subserve the supreme end of revoking the condemnation of Arianism.
Hence the confusion of counsels reflected in the multiplicity of
creeds. The result pleased no one. The Lucianic Creed, with its
anti-Arian clauses, tempered by equivocal qualifications, was a feeble
and indirect weapon against Marcellus, who could admit in a sense the
pre-æonian γέννησις and the
‘true’ sonship. On the other hand, the three creeds which
only succeeded in gaining secondary ratification, while express against
Marcellus, were worthless as against Arianism. On the whole, the fourth
creed, in spite of its irregular sanction, was found the most useful
for the time (341–351); but as their doctrinal position took
definite form, the Conservative wing fell back on the
‘Lucianic’ Creed, and found in it a bridge to the Nicene
(cf. pp. 470, 472, Hil. de Syn. 33, and Gwatkin, p. 119,
note).